Obama gives Patriot Act another year with no privacy protections

By Andrew McLemore
Saturday, February 27th, 2010 -- 11:23 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

barackobama20080821 b Obama gives Patriot Act another year with no privacy protectionsIf the Patriot Act hadn't been approved for another year, Sunday would have looked much different.

Sunday could have meant the government was no longer given permission to wiretap the phones of Americans and seize their records and property.

But since the bill was approved by Congressional Democrats earlier this week and signed into law by President Obama on Saturday, this Sunday is just another Sunday for Americans living with the Patriot Act.

To be fair, many Democrats asked for additional protections for the privacy rights of American citizens.

But Republicans said that would detract from the ability of the country's intelligence agencies to track down terrorists. Lacking a 60-vote supermajority in the Senate to pass the bill with the extra provisions, Democrats left them out.

Story continues below...

Democratic Rep. Jane Harman opposed the House's approval of the extension, citing abuses during the administration of President George W. Bush.

"While I strongly support using the most robust tools possible to go after terrorists, Congress must revise and narrow -- not extend -- Bush era policies," Harman said.

Glenn Greenwald of Salon.com had the following to say of the overwhelming support of the law's extension:

One of the strangest prongs of conventional Beltway wisdom is the lament that there is not enough  bipartisanship.  The opposite is true:  many of the most damaging acts inflicted on the country by Washington are enacted on a fully bipartisan basis -- the most destructive political act of this generation, the invasion of Iraq, was fully bipartisan, as were most of the post-9/11 civil liberties abuses and other Bush-era initiatives-- and, at least in certain areas, the harmonious joining together of Republicans and Democrats continues unabated.

Most publications and politicians expected Obama to sign the Patriot Act.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • davetribbett
    Good post here defining the Patriot Act and its ability to impose martial law on the country. Obama has consistently mislead American’s about his intentions, one lie after another. Thanks for the post.
  • nofreakingway
    Barack Obama is a compulsive liar. Nothing's going to get better whatsoever until everybody realizes this and institutes somebody who isn't a puppet that manipulates peoples' want for a better life in order to make the rich richer and the poor not only more poor, but more entangled in a situation where they're increasingly dependent on the government to herd them through life.

    It's becoming more and more politically incorrect to not want the government to control every aspect of the United States, and this has got to change.

    Change. Remember that word, Barry? I disapprove of you and your plans that have absolutely nothing to do with benefiting the people you serve.
  • MedfordTim
    "Meet the new boss, same as the old boss..." - Pete Townshend, visionary...
  • They have to be unamerican to be American these daze. Like destroying nations to save them.
  • sambaj
    So this was what the "Christmas underwear bomber" incident was all about!

    Check out an eye-witnesses account (MSM won't report).

    http://www.sott.net/articles/show/202368-Haskel...
  • I'm gonna pull out my tea-bag too, if this shit keeps passing!
  • mcquaidLA
    Change! It's the new Same!
  • sdfrewrfe
    If this legislation is so great, how come it has to keep being renewed instead of just made permanent?

    On a side note: Obama has summoned the silver-medalist US Olympic hockey team for disciplinary action. He's also increased the chocolate ration from 30 grams per day to 20.
  • Druthers
    We must be logical. When your back is to the wall, when "they" hate us for our freedoms there is only one solution.
    Abolish our freedoms and be loved by all.
  • mikeski
    Obama screwed up and did something right? Well I guess the law of averages would dictate that sooner or later he'd get one right!
  • Paul
    Ahhhh. A red jersey chicken-shit bonehead who thinks a leash on his neck and a lash across his chubby bottom are what he needs to survive. I'll bet you wear a leather thong and nipple rings under your suit don't cha?
  • mikeski
    Ahhhh, another lib with nothing intelligent to say so you start name calling and insulting. I'm hurt. Grow up, get a life, and start thinking like an adult.
  • Paul
    Lib huh? LOL. funny.

    So tell me, what intelligent adult prose could I have used to dissuade you from your apparrent support of the Patriot Act, a complete abomination to any American that understands its tenants, especially as they are back-dropped by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights?
  • mikeski
    Well my genius friend, let's start by letting me ask you why you think it is that it has to be re-approved on a yearly basis since you claim to understand it so well. We will go from there.
  • Paul
    Bzzzzt. wrong answer. I guess we'll have to go back to the name calling...
  • mikeski
    LMAO! I knew you wouldn't be able to answer that simple question! Thanks for proving once again that "libs" aren't interested in facts, all they want to do is call names and insult those that are more intelligent!
  • Paul
    Whadda fuckin' dolt. I asked you a question, you answer it with a question and then laugh your ass off? So again you chained ass, what intelligent adult prose could I have used to dissuade you from your apparrent support of the Patriot Act, a complete abomination to any American that understands its tenants, especially as they are back-dropped by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kNRSs6LsGeI
  • mikeski
    Look Genius,

    I asked you a VERY simple and VERY basic question about the Patriot Act, you are unable to answer that question which tells me that you haven't any understanding of the subject. The answer to your question is there is no intelligent adult prose that you could have used to dissuade me from my support of the Patriot Act because

    1. Unlike you I DO understand the act.

    2. You can't come up with any form of "adult prose"


    Go back to name calling and insults - I now understand why you do it, it's all you do understand.
  • mikeski
    Look Genius,

    I asked you a VERY simple and VERY basic question about the Patriot Act, you are unable to answer that question which tells me that you haven't any understanding of the subject. The answer to your question is there is no intelligent adult prose that you could have used to dissuade me from my support of the Patriot Act because

    1. Unlike you I DO understand the act.

    2. You can't come up with any form of "adult prose"


    Go back to name calling and insults - I now understand why you do it, it's all you do understand.
  • turo62
    Illegal wire tapping and indefinite detention without charge have now replaced privacy and the freedom to openly criticize your own government , as hallmarks of our country. The patriot act is probably the most dangerous document our country has ever had to endure. I'm amazed at the continual lack of outrage and slow but sure acceptance of this fascist rag. If you think I'm way of base here just see Professor Johnathan Turley's opinion..
  • So what's the true cover-up behind this thing? Perhaps something as simple as my own website, www.rickhyatt.freeservers.com - If you're really allowed to view the real thing...
  • DM3
    I bet you Obama extends the Bush tax cuts too...watch.
  • mikeski
    It would be asking too much for him to do two things right!
  • Paul
    what was the other pray tell?
  • Well Well Well
    Why are people still pretending the dems are repubs are not owned by the same people??
  • Well Well Well
    When are people going to stop talking about Dems and Repubs like they are different? When are people going to leave the whole left/right thing behind? THis is all done for the advantage of the corporately owned SINGLE PARTY government.
  • Well Well Well
    Its about tracking the Innocent people..not terrorists. Obama is the same as Bush if not worst with the spending and increasing the wars over seas.
  • thrashertm
    This should surprise no one, since Obama voted to re-authorize the Patriot Act while still a Senator. The fact that he's a Constitutional scholar supposedly is very disheartening, on many many levels.
  • OldAtlantic
    Obama has to go along with the establishment because he is not a natural born citizen.
  • Turnip
    No. It's because the Executive, whether black, white or orange, is not the decider. Far reaching policy like war and debt are way above their paygrade.
    Oh, go fusk yourself.
  • kentmueller
    I want to believe that many Dems and a few Republicans would like to roll this back. I think the Obama Administration would prefer to roll this back. With two wars -- one winding down and one winding up -- and the worst world economy since the 1930s there's a lot on the plate, Maybe the health care battle could have waited for 2011. This has been punted to next year. It's a one-year extension on three of the most egregious violations of traditional civil liberties.

    This isn't as bad as putting toothpaste back in the tube, more the equivalent of taking a large tangle of tape or film and carefully getting it back on a spool without creasing or damaging it. It can be rolled back. Liberties can be restored. There is an urgency to doing that, In 5 or 10 years, maybe sooner, we'll have a group of voters coming of age who have never known things to be different, and take the chill for granted. A voting generation is 10 to 15 years, with protesting voices fewer and farther between, gradually dying off, two generations are enough to kiss liberties goodby, forever.

    The political aspects are ugly. One dropped ball by the Democrats and they're back to being "Weak on Defense, weak on Security, weak on Terror," Doesn't help that sooner or later we will be attacked again by Al Quada or a franchisee, whether under a Dem or a Republican admin.,. Look what happened with (the failure of) the underwear bomber, it turned the public mood around and made civil liberty concerns, already pushed to the back burner by the economy, a nicety instead of the underpinning of democracy. We had the shoe bomber, the underwear bomber, still to come are the brown belt bomber, the undershirt bomber, the uplift bra bomber, the necktie, ascot and bandanna bombers, the Kongol and Stetson Hat bombers, and the shiny-pated bomber who tried to use an explosive mixture disguised as a baldness cure. Each event will ikely be foiled by a few alert passengers and crew and each will send people in small towns across the country looking anxiously under their beds for the terrorists they fear might be hiding there.

    Obama voted for the Patriot Act renewals in summer 2008 and the reality is if he hadn't the GOP would have used it like a hammer to paint him weak on security. By this date we might have been talking about the odd circumstances surrounding President Palin's succession to the highest office.

    It's an election year with vulnerable incumbents on both sides. Maybe they can't move until 2011, maybe Obama can't move on it until after 2012. But if it isn't pulled within five years or so, it never will be.

    How long can a real American democracy last if the duly-elected government operates on the assumption that any one of its 300 plus million citizens are each potential terrorists? Their every communication and every financial transaction must be at least combed for keywords and unusual patterns by high-speed computers and every hit will be analyzed.

    Woe to the 12 year-old kid who emails Grandma (she doesn't text) that the video game she sent him for his birthday is "the bomb". 200 agents spend the next six weeks determining that it's a 12 year-old, the video game isn't in fact a bomb (though the younger, hipper agents say it's pretty good) and the "Gramdma" isn't the code name for a fellow terrorist, maybe even a cell leader, woe to the gal who wins 600 dollars in a scratch-off lottery and prudently puts it in the bank, woe to the country traveler who takes a wrong turn, realizes their mistake and does a Y turn in the nearest driveway, a seemingly abandoned fenced-in area with a gate, that unknown to them is part of a military base. The innocent have nothing to fear.

    There is already mission drift. It's being used in purely criminal cases in violation of the charters of the agencies involved, and it's only a matter of time before it's being used for political advantage.

    .
  • Turnip
    There is already mission drift. It's being used in purely criminal cases in violation of the charters of the agencies involved, and it's only a matter of time before it's being used for political advantage

    And more importantly, it's been used, quite predictably, to stifle dissent, and create an environment of apathy and defeat. We, the people, are the abused in the 'Social Contract'.
    It is assumed that all protests will be tracked, all communications will be tracked, and that even this post will be vacuumed up and analyzed. These are not the actions of a free nation, or as importantly the responses of a truly free people. Freedom? Bullshit.
    Believe it after you read your Staatssicherheit file.
  • Boson Bison
    They don't track down terrorists. They don't fight crime. They don't stop drug trafficking, prostitution, violence, rape, money laundering, or cat juggling. All they do is demonize critics. Period.
  • Ez4moi
    Does it seem to anyone else like the Democratic Party demonized Republican politicians over several points like the Patriot Act only to keep them going now? Back when they were ranting about it, did they not know it was necessary? In other words, are not Democrats cynically motivated to demonize that which is known to them about how their base will react?
  • Boson Bison
    Instilling fear and crippling self-doubt in all of us stifles economic growth.
  • ObamaSucks
    Hope and change............uh-huh, sure.
  • zonkerzzzz
    I would like to introduce a bill to slaughter all non-Caucasian babies.
    I call it the Vanilla Ice Cream Act.
    Who could possibly vote against that?
  • benway
    Change you can believe in. Unless it involves giving up the illegitimate power of the president.
  • NadePaulKuciGravMcKi
    Passed both houses
    Signed on a Saturday
    All done in less than a week

    All done VERY quietly ~
  • well, npkg, had to be done quickly and quietly, can't have the electorate flooding congress with emails and petitions ...
  • libertate
    Man, you guys can sure pick a winner.
  • your guy would have had us in iran already and defaulting on our treasury bonds, putz
  • Paul
    That's it...keep defending your idiocy by claiming that it is a better form of idiocy than the other guy's idiocy...either which way, votes for either consisted of the hopes, dreams, and opinions of idiots...idiot.
  • well, paulie baby, like well well well says below, you must think that i'm stuck in the left vs right meme ... naw, i'm way past that ... i live way offshore outside your propaganda bubble.

    i never voted for our president because he, a constitutional scholar, showed his corporatist stripes and dishonored the constitution and the law as bush before him with a flip-flop on f.i.s.a. and green light to the oligarchy of war financiers and unelected elite - the true power.

    no, my comment to the asswipe who would have rather seen the mccain/palin ticket at the switch than the adults was clear - i (and i suspect even the oligarchy) know junkyard songbird mccain from before you were shitting yellow and i know the world would be singing 'duck and cover' within weeks of his inauguration given any opportunity.

    oh, and paulie, bite me! putz!
  • Paul
    Hmmmm. Apparently I identified you as a schmuck by mistake and in so doing, deserve the "Putz spanking". For this I apologize. I am simply conditioned to read "Blue-Jersey Sound-biter" into most of the one line responses around here. Once in a while the Red-Jersey variety shows his or her face as well. It gets frustrating, and impedes my level of discernment. Again, I apologies for assuming that you were one of them.
  • accepted and done ... live long and prosper
  • it seems the SUPER minority has used it's dominance to once again show the American people who knows best.

    Why continue to vote for democrats if they refuse to use the majority they are given? When I vote against my best interests, at least I know what the Republicans will do - they say how they will distroy the country and they stick to it! Democrats say one thing and then when the Republicans say boo they run scared and who knows what will happen... For me, I feel I can plan my life and my future around the planned destruction of the country but not around the Democrats and DINOs attempt to run the country...

    Good news is that my political donation budget can now go towards my under-mattress, American destruction budget...

    not to mention that Bushbama is now only one short breath away from the immorality of Bush 43... GWB will be there to great him at the gates of hell - if Cheney hasn't contracted that out...
  • Well Well Well
    You have to start thinking outside the left/Right, Dem/Repub, nonsense, that that is for is to keep people thinking they have two parties and it creates divisions between the people for the politicians gain.
  • Help me figure this out...
    Why is it that, as a lefty upposed to Barack Obama and the majority of his politics, I am constantly accused of being a "tea bagger" on this website? I've been accused on here of voting for "Repubicants" and of being a "hate monger" when I've NEVER voted for a Republican, I am a staunch lifelong anti-war protestor (and that goes back to the 60's), and I work to ensure that the criminal George W. Bush and his evil criminal minions will go to prison. I don't understand many Raw Story readers who somehow feel that I am related to the tea party movement because I know that Barack Obama is NWO, that he'll never be ALLOWED to stop the wars, and that he is knee deep in it, just like Bush was. My deepest feelings are that we, as Americans, missed the warnings given to us by both Eisenhower and Kennedy, a Republican and a Democrat, that something was amiss. Eisenhower warned us of the Military Industrial Complex, we failed to heed his warnings. Kennedy warned us of the dangers of Secret Societies i.e. CIA, NWO, we failed to heed his warnings. Now, 50 years later, we are feeling much of the effects of what these two great men tried to warn us about. The CIA so feared Kennedy that they killed him, and his brother and MLK, JR., because these men were about PEACE. Ever since the CIA killed Kennedy, the government of the USA has been illegitimate. Now, we are being ROBBED BLIND BY A CRIMINAL INDUSTRY SET ON DESTROYING THE USA. For those Americans who have yet to wake up, this is not about LEFT VS. RIGHT, this is about a takeover of America on the highest levels by a group of criminals so hidden within the fabric of American government and American industry that they are, quite frankly, invisible. I AM NOT A TEA BAGGER, I AM AN AMERICAN WHO LOVES MY COUNTRY AND IS, QUITE FRANKLY, MAD AS H*LL BECAUSE OF WHAT THE CROOKS AND CRIMINALS IN CHARGE HAVE DONE TO AMERICA. YES, WE ARE AT WAR. KNOW YOUR ENEMY!
  • Buckfutter
    Actually it goes back a lot further than that. Both Abraham Lincoln and Thomas Jefferson warned us about the threat that corporations pose to freedom and democracy.

    As for the Teabaggers, even though they were/ are a bunch of ignorant dolts manipulated by Corporate America, it was encouraging to see the beginnings of Americans coming together to challenge this system. Now it appears the Teabag Party has been infiltrated by George Bush loving pro- war neoconservatives.They now stand for many of the things that Ron Paul and their original members opposed. This country is now so thoroughly corrupt that even a party of fringe lunatics is quickly infiltrated and corrupted. So sad.
  • Paul
    Lincoln? He was a tool for them as well...
  • yaright
    I voted for obama but now that I will be forced to buy health insurance and him allowing and continuing this Unconstitutional Orwellian Bullshit.... I guess I will sit out the next two elections and see what happens. Democrats! You better wake up. You will piss us all off and then where will you be? Up ole shits creek with your patriot act, taxation without representation paddle.
  • the constitution is now just a piece of paper in a museum with some fancy penmanship...
  • TaterSalad
    Thank you Mr. President for extending the Patriot Act.....again! GWB and you must think alike except for the fact that you are a big Hypocrit. Wasn't it you who campaigned on this very Act as being un-American, yet now you are extending it! What a fool!

    http://biggovernment.com/sahiller/2010/02/28/ob...

    All these left wing loons aren't going to respond to this one I bet. Lets see who has the balls now!
  • Guest
    yes because it's important to SPY on US Citizens, jeezuz Obama wtf
  • Political Gangsta
    ahhhh yes, 'Change we can believe in" LMAO!!!
    Feeling duped YET, oh faithful liberal democrats? Obama still your man? Your saviour?
    www.myspace.com/thepoliticalgangsta
  • charlesrinko
    LOL, wasnt he originally against the patriot act? Hmm, Why should he be any different than those before him! LOL

    Jess
    www.total-anonymity.cz.tc
  • He was against it when it gave power to someone else! He is for it now that it gives HIM power!
  • lincolnparadox
    Huh? Well, unless Obama fixes the economic crisis by January 2012, or single-handedly captures Osamabin Laden, I think this is proof positive that he will be a one-term President.

    Especially since the current HUD program has been quietly moving African Americans from the big cities to smaller, suburban communities in other (whiter) states.
  • thelonegunman
    glad i voted for 'change'....

    meet the new boss, same as the old boss
  • MedfordTim
    DOH! Sorry, didn't read down in the comments far enough to realize I was duplicating.
  • sparkey
    I was thinking that "one more" over half of congress and the senate is all that is needed to pass or delete a bill. But, then I remembered that democrats in congress and the senate are spineless cowards who piss down their legs every time a republican looks at them.
  • Paul
    What is it about you people that you somehow feel the need to continue to support your shitty decisions by giving the Democrats some small percentage of a bye in all of this? How can you possibly be so demented as to think for a second that if not for the Republicans, they would somehow "get the job done"...as you see the job....that they are "afraid" is somehow an understandable reason and therfor excuses your misplaced faith in their doing the right thing. It's like Republicans claiming that Reagan WOULD HAVE been a great conservative if it weren't for thew Democrats who scared him into inflating the money supply. Great real.

    Christ, don't you get it yet, that they are all part of one party and you are kept in the bleachers watching the game that is about as much a competition as the WWF is? It is really tiring to heasr this crap like the Bush/Cheney crime family has the mon o[poly on war mongering and subterfuge. Go back in history a block or two, or three, or four and see who weilded the power wehn other wars were started, and understand thte popitical subterfuger used to gert us into those wars was weilded by the Democrats.

    Jeez, it doesn't matter! The game is rigged and you, the fan in the seat, donning your blue jersey...along with your red jersey counterparts are the ultimate losers. They will keep you watching and routing at the top of your lungs as they keep the game close with all hinging on the Hail Hary play in the supposed end...but it will only mean a tie and more game in endless overtime...and in the overtime, while you are not looking they'll re-set the clock. They are all the same party...and you ain't one of them.
  • douvie
    More fuel to legitimize the radical right. There is nothing so soothing as a supposed democratic government seized by a minority of crazies. Way to go, Dems.
  • Lyman
    Of course they need the Patriot Act since they find the people revolting.
  • Nickelthrower
    They do find us "revolting" but, as you must admit, with the end of the big free lunch just around the corner, these people are going to need all power that the Patriot Act can offer. Public protest will be relabeled an act of terrorism.

    Orange Jumpsuits For Everyone!
  • voteoutalltheincumbents
    OK, so where is the whole "change the way we do business in Washington" thing this idiot promised?
  • BUDDAH
    HOPE AND CHANGE BARRY PATHETIC! HE SHOULD WATERBOARDED WITH CONGRESS AND THE BANKERS! HOPE AND CHANGE HMMMMMMMM!
  • seen2much
    I wrote in Ron Paul, so my conscience is just fine..

    Must really suck to know you voted for the guy that will be blamed by history for the collapse of America. You pathetic mccain voters don't get a free pass on this either, as far as I'm concerned you are JUST as guilty.

    You should have stayed home, both of you, at least then you wouldn't have documented proof of your part in the unfolding collapse.
  • Mike
    I voted for Obama but I told myself that if he sells out, I'll never vote in another federal election. I am just tired of the same old crap.

    Of course, Obama not only sold out, he sold out lock, stock and barrel. For all my cynicism, even I didn't expect such a total betrayal.

    I have had it with this country. For all I care you can turn it over to loonies like Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin. Elect them, so that they can put this country out of its misery.
  • mikeski
    I'm shocked you didn't see it coming. It's not a dig either. What confuses me is that there were so many people that were "fooled" by him. I didn't vote for the clown, I saw he was an idiot and a liar from the start. He tried to make everyone feel good during the election. I PRAY Romney runs in 2012!
  • Romney? Really?
    Why? That makes no sense...

    Romney backs interrogation, Patriot Act - USATODAY.com
    http://www.usatoday.com/news/topstories/2007-07...
  • mikeski
    "Why? That makes no sense...



    Romney backs interrogation, Patriot Act"

    So do I genius! That clear it up for you?
  • Paul
    Ummm Mandika, so does Mikeski...
  • Turnip
    Because you've evidenced the fact that there is no functional difference in a R or a D, you have a duty to vote in every frikkin election, you whiny quitter. Your vote, should reflect your knowledge. That is what a rational and thinking person would do.
    If this emerging wisdom doesn't eventually move the vote or bring back a greater political voice to the people, then they have the further duty to disband the current criminals, and reconvene a constitutionally accountable administration.
    If neither happens, I suspect that the entire country will look like Detroit does in less than twenty years.
  • Paul
    For as long as people feel like you, nothing will change...which is exactly what THEY want. I couldn't write in Ron Paul so I chose Chuck Baldwin. The last thing I was going to do was lend any portion of my integrity to either of the asshole's put forth by the cabal.
  • Well Well Well
    Ron Paul is not put forth by the cabal, they tried to get him out and they ridiculed in on live tv, that should have been a huge green sign to vote for him. But sheep are dumb and can't see these things.
  • Paul
    Are you agreeing with and echoing me or somehow misgudedly trying to educate me that Ron Paul is not put forth by the cabal? AS I said, I couldn't write him in...after running as a delegate for him BTW...so I cast my electronic vote for Baldwin...or whoever it was that received my tally. I'd just as soon case my vote for Nader or McKinney given my perception of them as honest people trying to make a DIFFERENCE.
  • libertate
    "I'll never vote in another federal election. I am just tired of the same old crap."

    I concur.
  • North Korea
    Two party slave!

    There are other options to voting for crime syndicate R or crime syndicate D.
  • NadePaulKuciGravMcKi
    A real 'Man of the People'

    Mr Uncle Tom
    puppet poodle
blog comments powered by Disqus