US military spied on Planned Parenthood, civilian phone calls

By John Byrne
Friday, February 26th, 2010 -- 9:43 am
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

plannedparenthood3 US military spied on Planned Parenthood, civilian phone callsUnited States military intelligence spied on Planned Parenthood and other domestic groups as part of US security preparations for the 2002 winter Olympics in Salt Lake City, according to a recently declassified military document obtained by a civil liberties group Thursday.

The document (PDF - page 98), drafted by a Pentagon Deputy Inspector General whose name is redacted, was included in more than 800 pages released to the Electronic Frontier Foundation as part of a Freedom of Information Act Request. They include reports from the Pentagon's Intelligence Oversight Board that were submitted to the Defense Secretary from 2001 to 2007.

Referring to an incident where military intelligence personnel distributed information about FBI spying on the 2002 Olympics, the inspector general's office tersely remarked that an "intelligence oversight violation occurred."

"The document... contained US Persons data in referring to an reporting on organizations (Planned Parenthood, the white supremacist group National Alliance) and their involvement in protests and literature distribution," the inspector's office wrote. "Also noted was the report contained a large section labeled "GENERAL CRIMINAL ACTIVITY." Collection and dissemination of US Persons information by military intelligence assets is not allowed unless this information constitutes "Foreign Intelligence."

"The inclusion of these two sections in this intelligence product is clearly outside the purview of military intelligence assets and should be handled through law enforcement or Anti-Terrorism/Force Protection channels," the inspector's office added. "An inquiry into the circumstances of this violation was conducted and the result will be forwarded via separate correspondence."

Story continues below...

 US military spied on Planned Parenthood, civilian phone calls

Electronic Frontier Foundation also notes that military intelligence spied on the anti-war group Alaskans for Peace and Justice in 2005 (pages 122-137), and that NORAD had "procedural problems" relating to spying on "US Persons" (pp. 257-258).

Despite a clear violation of military protocol and probable violation of US law, such reports are rarely made public. These documents were only made public under the Freedom of Information Act and were not scheduled for release.

"Intelligence oversight reporting is rarely disclosed to the public," EFF's Nate Cardozo noted in a posting about the documents on Thursday.

"Much of the reported improper activity consisted of intelligence gathering on so-called “U.S. Persons,” including citizens, permanent residents and U.S.-based organizations," Cardozo added. "Although Defense agencies are generally prohibited from collecting such information (except as part of foreign intelligence or counter-intelligence activity), it is apparent from the unredacted reports released to EFF that some DoD components have had chronic difficulty complying with that prohibition."

Wired's Kim Zetter notes that the documents provide no context or background about how or why the Pentagon spied on Planned Parenthood and other groups.

"The reports provide little context for the information that’s disclosed, leaving the public to wonder about the nature and extent of the information and surveillance revealed in them," Zetter wrote. "Pertaining to the Planned Parenthood members, for example, the oversight report provides no explanation about how the information was collected. Nor does it indicate why the information was collected."

In another possible legal violation, military officers listened into civilian cellphone calls in 2007. Zetter explains:

Another oversight document discusses an incident involving the interception of civilian cellphone conversations of U.S. persons in April 2007. During a field exercise at Fort Polk, Louisiana, a Signals Intelligence noncommissioned officer operating a SIGINT collection system intercepted the cell phone calls, though the document doesn’t indicate if they were intercepted on U.S. soil or outside U.S. borders.

Initial reports indicated that the officer listened to the conversations for entertainment purposes, and the incident was reported to the National Security Agency. But the inspector-general document indicates that the officer never admitted to this and indicates only that he may have listened to some conversations “longer than necessary to do his job.”

Electronic Frontier Foundation has more analysis and details of the newly released documents here.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • shalomjaye
    This spying was done partly by the OSI. Please see the AF Academy Rapes and UFO DIS, MIS Information and they do not even have a TV show like “NCIS” does and a few of their Agents were busted for being Pedophiles and Dirty agents.
    The OSI are Feds and here is their Mental/ Psy Profile:
    1 Very suspicious and distrustful of anyone not of their own culture.
    2 Too self-assured and self confident, to need, or ask for help is perceived as a sign of weakness, value self-reliance seeking help for any issue.
    3 May possess above-average intelligence.
    4 Perfectionist; overly judgmental of self &others, takes great pride in profession not wanting to bring any shame on it or themselves
    5 Over identify with job resulting in isolating with others in culture which leads to alienation; great deal of personal identify tied up in professional identity; it’s much more that just a job, it’s a way of life.
    6 Crisis oriented; seek & thrive on excitement & stress; always want to be “in the thick of things”
    7 Defensive & trend to overreact when challenged; take charge personality
    8 Difficulty dealing with feelings valuing cognitive abilities; repression of feelings is a self-protecting mechanism; projection & rationalization used to cope with distress which tends to encourages maladaptive behaviors often resulting in maladies such as depression, despair, loneliness, & cynicism.
    9 Resistant to surrendering self-control; “powerlessness” is considered a sign of weakness
    10 Tendency to equate physical health with mental health; physical and mental illness are perceived, sometimes rightly so, as career damaging or ending; treatment for any affliction, especially perceived “mental illnesses” is viewed unsafe and career damaging; very stigma oriented.
    11 Being deceptive and manipulative is a valuable trait; Feds are trained in techniques of dealing with deceptive persons and in interviewing skills
    12 Resistant to change; tend to view things in black or white, right or wrong. Travis K. Sorrows and J. Edgar Hoover
    Shalom, ShaJ
  • Farking Christ
    Collecting intell for the murder of Tiller? I wouldn't put it past them. The Christian coup goes on. I have to get out of here! One of these days I am going to have a suicide or a plane crash.
  • srmark
    I don't know what to say -- wish I knew someone living in Switzerland, Sweden or some other more freedom-loving country...
  • michaelvalentine
    Domestic spying and propagandizing to the American public is illegal for the Pentagon. Time to start firing and locking up law breakers.
  • kscitydude
    Hear that? That was the sound of the Founding Fathers bones hitting one another as they turned over in their graves.
  • Hooker
    PP has nothing to worry about. The U.S. military spied on bin Laden, as well. He seems to be doing just fine.
  • tyhth
    Great cover for a terrorist to talk about the need for birth control and its various methods so the NSA will hang up beforwe the important terrorist conversation. heh
  • quit being dumb
    you guys are dumb, this article is dumb, the govt doesnt do this shit intentionally, you are reading into this too much. paranoid fucks!
  • carol h.
    Too bad we can't redact the whole pentagon. What a corrupt country. There are no end to the revelations. But after the last ten years, there are no surprises, just revelations.

    Too bad these men in the pentagon, had parents that did not go to Planned Parenthood. These people are the best reason for birth control.
  • texasaggie
    And people wonder why a majority of respondents to a poll said that the government was a threat to our liberties and our freedom?
  • Power to the People
    Start shooting a few Pentagon officials and they'll soon get the message.

    "But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security."
  • MakeChessNotWar
    We need to expose the individuals who committed the crimes and send them to jail. Domestic spies need to be identified and prosecuted, wither in the courts or in the streets.
  • PeteWa
    And the teabaggers insipidly scratch their nuts and look away...
  • habu99
    Where is the wingnut outrage over "big, intrusive government" due to this story? (Crickets).

    Oh yeah, protecting individual citizens from the wealthy and corporations overreaching their legality is seen as "big government" and intrusive. But turning the government into a giant police state that spies on its citizens (for their own "protection" of course) is business as usual.
  • piltdown
    Yeah, but it was Planned Parenthood. The right-wing is JUST FINE with that. Just like they're be just fine if it were ACORN offices that were being spied upon.
  • margaretpoa
    If there was ever a "duh" moment....
  • the higher-ups
    Just another bump on the road to TOTALITARIANISM!
  • Guest
    In Bushworld anything was possible and here we stand today. They're STILL listening to us for "entertainment" much like some cops harass people -- because they can. We used to be a nation of laws, not anymore.
  • robertfromphila
    Can those people who have been victims of illegal and unconstitutional spying, wiretap, and search have civil claims against the gov't and if these violations were criminal, do they have the satisfaction of knowing that the gov't will clean its dirty laundry and prosecute for the people. Or will this, like every other civil rights violation committed for Bush/Cheney control and fear mongering, be swept under the rug in the interest of looking forward and not backward?
  • ctcadguy
    Little known fact - The US lost the Olympics due to the fact we are a police state.

    Did not want a False Flag incident like 911 and the Anthrax attacks during the Olympics.

    US will never get another Olympics because the rest of the world knows about us.
  • piltdown
    "The US lost the Olympics due to the fact we are a police state."

    Yeah, that's why they were held in CHINA!

    *slaps you upside the head*

    If you're going to make an outburst, at least put some damned thought into it.
  • bobdevo
    Welcome to the Glorious Fifth Reich. All hail the Leader and the Homeland.
  • disappointedvoter
    War is peace, freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength.
  • bobdevo
    We have always been at war with Terror.
  • Pseudolus
    So we're all East Germans now.

    Great.
  • Ross Wolf
    Could local, state and federal “Fusion Centers” be used to provide information about law bidding Americans to a Secret Police State?

    Since 9/11 U.S. Government has established a large number Fusion Centers across the Nation that rely on local informants and databases to collect information that might prevent terrorism, then share the information with different state, local and federal law enforcement agencies. But more recently Fusion Centers shifted away from their stated mission to pursing all crimes and hazards; and now share confidential information about Americans who have nothing to do with Crime or Terrorism. Fusion Centers to circumvent Citizens’ Fourth Amendment Rights, take advantage of ambiguous lines of authority to manipulate differences in federal, state and local laws to maximize information collection. The Centers increasingly involve components of the U.S. Military in addition to other government entities to spy on Citizens. Recently the Department of Homeland Security began sharing more classified Military information with local Fusion Centers; perhaps a mistake, historically local police don’t kept secrets. Because some Fusion Centers appear to operate more independently than others, it is not possible to generalize the mission of Fusion Centers.

    Because Fusion Centers exchange information with select U.S. private sector companies; that has enabled fusion centers to escape accountability and public oversight.
    In retrospect, Hitler created a “Civilian National Security Force”, the Gestapo the contraction of Geheime Staatspolizei for "Secret State Police." In 1934 the Gestapo was placed under SS leader Heinrich Himmler the Chief of German Police. Thereafter in 1939 all German Police agencies were put under the control of the "Reich Main Security Office” the equivalent of U.S. Homeland Security. Does this Nazi consolidation of German law enforcement including its Secret Police under its "Main Security Office” sound familiar?
  • Pseudolus
    Only too familiar, Ross– But with regard to US private sector companies– look at the bright side, I understand if you join the FBI's Infragard, you get a neat secret decoder ring.
  • whatacountry09
    Who cares????? Obviously NOBODY BECAUSE THE DEMOCRATS JUST LET THE PATRIOT ACT GO BY WITHOUT ANY REVISIONS... AND NOT ENOUGH AMERICANS ARE OUTRAGED ENOUGH TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT, NOT TO MENTION MOST DON'T EVEN KNOW BECAUSE IT'S BLACKED OUT OF THE MEDIA AND GOD FORBID... PEOPLE ACTUALLY RESEARCH STUFF ON THEIR OWN TO ENSURE AWARENESS. NAAAAA WHY BOTHER... THEY RELY ON THE NO. 1 TRUSTED NAME IN THE NEWS INDUSTRY... FOX!!!!!!!!
  • rosswolf
    U.S. Government despite promises that Einstein 3 would not invade private email and other private communications in its fight against terrorists has habitually broken those promises in the past (NSA Spying) on private electronic communications that don’t involve terrorism and to arrest U.S. Citizens for alleged ordinary crimes.

    Neither Congress nor the courts—determined what warrant-less NSA electronic surveillance could be used by police or introduced into court by U.S. Government to prosecute Citizens and foreign businesses doing business in America. It appears NSA can share its electronic-domestic-spying with countless U.S. police agencies; including government contracted companies and private individuals that have security clearances to facilitate criminal and civil prosecutions that may include forfeiture of Americans’ property—-to keep part of the assets. Police too easily can take an innocent person’s “wiretapped” hastily written email, fax or phone call out of context to allege a crime or violation was committed.

    There are over 200 U.S. laws and violations mentioned in the Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act of 2000 and the Patriot Act that can subject property to civil asset forfeiture.” Under federal civil forfeiture laws, a person or business need not be charged with a crime for government to forfeit their property. Government is required only to show “A preponderance of Evidence” to civilly forfeit assets. Rep. Henry Hyde’s bill HR 1658 passed, the “Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act of 2000” and effectively eliminated the “statue of limitations” for Government Civil Asset Forfeiture. The statute now runs five years from when police allege they “learned” that an asset became subject to forfeiture.
  • sdfrewrfe
    All CAPS? Resisting the USAPATRIOT Act? Questioning the media, especially FOX? Encouraging common people to investigate for themselves? I have no choice but to report you, whatacountry09, if that is indeed your real name, to The United States Department of Fatherland Security. Please stay where you are.
  • whatacountry09
    you made me smile... thank you!!!!!!!!!
  • 143
    Couldn't have said it better! You nailed it!
  • MakeChessNotWar
    Would have gotten a "like" if you had unstuck your CAPS LOCK key.
  • whatacountry09
    I don't 'need' your 'like'... and my caps (for the record) is not me 'screaming'... it's "STRONG EMPHASIS". If and when I'm screaming... I preface my sentences to reflect that. So... my dear, thank you anyway... because not 'liking' my statement for a technicality... is still liking it. :)
  • Joe
    The Ron Paul Revolution cares. We have principles (remember those?!). Join us!!
  • srmark
    Ron Paul is on-target in foreign policy but his economic views are right-wing lassiez-faire which is in effect more predatory-capitalism..how could any progressive support him then??
  • Craig B
    I'll join if he runs again. I've learned my lesson.
  • whatacountry09
    Yeah, I do remember The Revolution of Ron Paul and I did/do like a lot of things about him, but in all honesty... for some reason, I'm a little skeptical about him. I can't name what it is exactly that makes me feel like that, but I will do my research and get back to you. :)
  • shinyorbs
    I'll pass thank you.
  • Savantster
    while near 90% of Americans got a bigger pay check last year, based on a new tax cut, only 6% of the population knew they got the cut.

    Most people don't know what's going on, and don't care.. American Idol is on!
  • cooper
    That's because we're in a time where a tax cut doesn't mean much. We have much bigger issues to deal with. What good is a little tax cut when your government is creating a police state and won't do a damn thing about it? We still have warrantless wiretapping, rendition, state secrets, torture issues, Guantanamo, the Patriot Act, and no public option healthcare. I can go on. But at this point a tax cut feels more like a bribe.
  • dennycrane
    Good point, but they would never admit it. Even if you put the coins in a sock and beat them with it.
  • How about a PSA.

    Left half of the screen, shows what a family should do, while the right side of the screen shows a family watching idol.

    Make it time-lapsed.

    As they get closer to the winner of IDOL, the family who lobbies runs into red tape.

    End with message that the Toolbox to maintain America is broken.. bla bla bla plug website.
  • whatacountry09
    I know. And... what's worse is that my new fear is that because most don't see 'any' of the 'good' Obama is doing... my fear is that they will NOT come out and vote for him for his second term and that WILL BE a mistake; a HUGE mistake. Of the two... we are better off with Obama... and if he wants to stay in office for a second term... he needs to act on 'don't ask/don't tell', REVERSE MANY BUSH POLICIES, 'revise the patriot act', make a public option available or at least mandate lower premiums across the board and most of all... push stuff through w/out the support of the other side because they will only vote against anything he tries to do anyway.
  • trippin
    What's the difference? Dumbass America has been fear-mongered into believing being spied on is for their own safety. After all, if you have nothing to hide, why not cooperate with the Gestapo?
  • dennycrane
    They have a "perfect" porn-storm now. Mix this bullshit in with the TSA's "body" scanners and ""pat" downs and it's "3D" tory-porn.
blog comments powered by Disqus