GOP senator slammed for being lone holdout blocking veterans’ health bill

By David Edwards and Daniel Tencer
Thursday, November 12th, 2009 -- 4:19 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

tomcoburnoklahoma GOP senator slammed for being lone holdout blocking veterans health billSen. Tom Coburn is taking political heat this week for blocking a vote on a bill that would significantly expand access to health care for American veterans, despite broad bipartisan support for the measure.

Using a Senate procedure known as a "hold," Coburn (R-OK) has single-handedly stopped the Caregivers and Veterans Omnibus Health Services Act of 2009 from moving forward, and in the process exposed himself to accusations of hypocrisy, acting "illogically" and acting "shamefully."

The bill is designed to address the health needs of at least some of the roughly 1.5 million US veterans who are not currently covered by the military's health system. It would also provide assistance to veterans' caregivers.

Coburn argues he cannot allow the bill to proceed because it doesn't address how its $3.7-billion tab will be paid for. The Oklahoma senator is known as a fierce fiscal conservative, but critics of his move to block the veterans' bill say he is acting hypocritically, because he has in the past voted in favor of emergency war spending bills that had much larger tabs than the vets' bill.

"Sen. Coburn's rule on that, of course, did not constrain him from voting for funding for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan that made this veterans' bill necessary," MSNBC's Rachel Maddow said Wednesday night. "Funding for wars that wasn't offset by anything."

Story continues below...

Added Maddow: "Those wars which Sen. Coburn was perfectly happy to vote to pay for with absolutely no explanation of how we would cover those costs created 1.7 million new American veterans. He is now on principle not willing to pay for taking care of those veterans."

Maddow quoted Coburn as saying that "90 percent" of veterans would agree with his stance against the bill. But, as the Marine Corps Times notes, 13 military and veterans' advocacy groups have banded together to pressure Coburn to let the bill move forward.

"It's shameful and it's outrageous," US House Rep. Joe Sestak (D-PA) told Maddow. A former US Navy rear admiral, Sestak said: "We ask these men and women, my fellow vets, to go overseas and protect our lives and then they come home and he doesn't want to protect them?"

Equally strong words came from Alaska Democratic Senator Mark Begich: "There is no excuse for not supporting our veterans and their caregivers. They have earned it and they have earned better than what they have been provided up to date. The hold is unjustified and obstructing the Senate from fulfilling its obligations to our veterans."

Earlier this week, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid called Coburn's move "illogical."

“Where was he when we were spending a trillion dollars on the war in Iraq?” Reid asked. “That wasn’t paid for. I didn’t hear him stopping the bill from going forward at that time. I think he should become more logical and understand we have people who are suffering.”

Sestak suggested that Coburn may be willing to take the controversial position because he has been conditioned by Washington's attitude that only military strength is a reflection of a strong society -- an interesting point for a former naval admiral to make.

"It's what irks me most about Washington, DC," he said. "Somehow they think strength is purely military force, not understanding it's our people, and they have forgotten that, particularly in this case."

On Wednesday, Veterans Day, researchers at Harvard University published a study showing that 2.266 veterans died last year due to a lack of health insurance.

This video is from MSNBC's The Rachel Maddow Show, broadcast Nov. 11, 2009.



Download video via RawReplay.com

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • CarolAll
    Can't you just see him waving the flag and standing solemnly with his hand over his heart while he listened to the bugles play taps on Veteran's Day? I could almost hear Coburn rallying the crowds for the "War on Terra" and leading them in cheering "Suport Our Troops!" Since 2005, Coburn voted several times to approve unfunded Bush bills and amendments. Now that the Democrats are in power, Coburn's become a strict fiscal conservative. THe "strong on defense" Republican is quick to send American troops off to war, but he's turned around to deny them benefits now that they are home.

    The Senator from OK deserves to be tarred and feathered.
  • dennycrane
    I have feathers. Season 2 episode 6.
  • Looks like your memory is still A-Ok! Your fears about Alzheimer are totally exaggerated.
    :D
  • Fred
    Senator Coburn:
    Military Service: NONE
  • luschnig
    Coburn proves that if you wrap yourself in enough flags you can stand up in the Senate and say, "Fuck the Veterans" and Oklahomans at least will think you're a patriot.
  • Michael Valentine
    Way to support the troops, not.
  • badgerca
    A republican hypocrite? Say it isn't so? Shocking!
  • RobGinChicago
    Harry Reid doesn't have to respect the "Hold". He can do to Coburn wht he did to Chris Dodd, a fellow Democrat, and overruled the "Hold" that Dodd had placed on the FISA/Telecom retroactive immunity bill. Typical Democratic "leadership", save your hardball tactics for your own team.
  • rxgary
    reid and skankhosi are going to single handedly eliminate the dem majority
  • chrisinva
    Senator Coburn is a medical doctor who knows more about medicine (and paying for it) than the other 99 of them combined. I think most of us trust our doctor more than we trust our politicians, and in this case Dr. Coburn is a doctor we can trust.
  • kiboshki
    As a medical doctor, he should know that soldiers who don't go to war are cheaper than soldiers who get shot up in war.

    So why did he vote for the expensive wars and shooting up soldiers again?
  • Guest
    CORRECTION chriSINva: Senator Coburn is not a real medical doctor - he is an ignorant hillbilly who knows nothing about the world except for the wealthy criminals who no doubt surround his every moment - and who fund this piece of humanoid garbage. He's more like a Dr. Mengele than anyone we should trust.
  • Showdown0_0
    Dr. Coburn charged Medicaid and Medicare up the ass then ran for the Senate to protect the millions he raped the taxpayers for! So go peddle your wares on the streets of Bagdad and maybe you will gain some brains but I don't really believe that.
  • Savantster
    .
    What a bazaar, feeble attempt at logic. Not to mention, plenty of politicians are doctors, and if you can't trust a politician, how can you trust a doctor politician? .. they are still a politician.

    You should go back to the corner and eat your boogers and leave the thinking to the sane adults.
    .
  • doolindalton
    Oh PULEEZE! How on God's green earth can you justify THIS?! Are you one of those that sport a "Support Our Troops", "American Flag", "God Bless The USA" magnetic sign or yard sign like every other car and house in Oklahoma?! Do you proceed to then attack your neighbor for not worshipping in the same church as yours and vote in your political leaders according to 'faith'?! Do you also agree with the idiotic, intrusive and painful notion of displaying a woman's decision to end a pregnancy by posting it for the world to see?!! Do you believe that broad scale, half hazard, don't give a shit about anybody else, broad scale chemical crop dusting is okay even when it kills a persons garden, fruit trees, pets, livestock, contaminates water sources and in some cases destroys their LIVELIHOOD okay?! Oklahoma politics are....RIDICULOUS!!
  • another example of gop hypocrisy ... i'll bet he rode around in a suv with a 'support the troops' magnet made in china, too.
  • The real problem here is the special power a single Senator has to hold a bill. This is unconstitutional and undemocratic, and this has to change. If only Harry Reid had the spine to fight all this nonsense!
  • Notorious Kelly
    One million disabled veterans languishing in poverty in the VA benefits backlog.

    U.S. civilian casualties pale in comparison.
  • thelonegunman
    what's the shock? another repug chickenhawk who loves sending soldiers into harms' way and then balks at spending money for their care, who instead loves to send it to his corporate handlers...
  • mledford27613
    I understand the want to know how we are going to pay for things BUT considering how many bills he has passed without giving 2 cents about where the funding was coming from this is total hypocrisy. Let him know how you feel instead of just blogging about it phone, fax, and email as many times as you can so he gets the message. Send this to every veteran you know and all those that support those of us who have volunteered so others didn't have to be drafted.

    Senator Tom Cobern
    Washington D.C.:
    172 Russell Senate Office Bldg.
    Washington, DC 20510
    Main: 202-224-5754
    Fax: 202-224-6008

    Tulsa:
    1800 South Baltimore
    Suite 800
    Tulsa, OK 74119
    Main: 918-581-7651
    Fax: 918-581-7195

    Oklahoma City:
    100 North Broadway
    Suite 1820
    Oklahoma City, OK 73102
    Main: 405-231-4941
    Fax: 405-231-5051

    http://coburn.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseA...
blog comments powered by Disqus