Secretary Gates signs order barring release of torture photos

By Stephen C. Webster
Saturday, November 14th, 2009 -- 12:00 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

torturepics Secretary Gates signs order barring release of torture photosPursuant to new powers delegated to him by Congress, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates has executed an order blocking the release of photos depicting the torture of detainees. In doing so, it becomes highly unlikely that the Supreme Court will further consider making the photos public, as a lower court had ordered.

In a new supplemental brief [PDF link] filed with the high court, the administration's attorneys argue that the new law Congress passed to allow Gates this authority effectively exempts the photos from the Freedom of Information Act, therefore invalidating an earlier lawsuit.

"It now seems likely that today's action will put an end to the issue, making it unnecessary for the court to hear the case," MSNBC reported.

The American Civil Liberties Union, which sought the photos' release, had urged Secretary Gates to release the photos. In an open letter [PDF link], the ACLU said the images must be seen because they show the "pervasiveness" of abuse across Iraq and Afghanistan and that it was "aberrational."

"The government has previously asserted that disclosing these photographs poses risks in part because it is a 'particularly critical time' in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan," ACLU attorneys Jameel Jaffer and Alexander A. Abdo noted at the letter's conclusion. "We accordingly ask that you review any decision to withhold any photographs every ninety days to account for changing circumstances."

Story continues below...

"In order to withhold the photos, Gates simply had to certify, as he did in the court filing, that 'public disclosure of these photographs would endanger citizens of the United States, members of the United States Armed Forces, or employees of the United States Government deployed outside the United States,'" Mother Jones reporter Nick Baumann noted. "In other words, their release had to endanger someone, somewhere. And in the unlikely event that Gates had to stretch the truth to make that certification, it wouldn't matter, since there's no provision in the law that allows any court to review Gates' determination or rule on whether it was truthful."

In a release condemning the president's signature of the law allowing Gates to block the photos, Jaffer continued: "Secretary Gates should be guided by the importance of transparency to the democratic process, the extraordinary importance of these photos to the ongoing debate about the treatment of prisoners and the likelihood that the suppression of these photos would ultimately be far more damaging to national security than their disclosure. The last administration's decision to endorse torture undermined the United States' moral authority and compromised its security. A failure to fully confront the abuses of the last administration will only compound these harms."

The Supreme Court is expected to react by Monday.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • Suppression of evidence of war crimes does not make the crimes go away. It simply adds to the list of accessories to the crimes, and those obstructing justice. Unless "and justice for all" only applies to a certain "all" but not others.
  • disappointedvoter
    As far as I'm concerned, the inaction of Obama, Pelosi, and all the rest of that crowd amounts to war crimes all by itself.
  • Mooftown
    and that's because you are a complete tool and a moron :)
  • disappointedvoter
    You think that because you are a war criminal sympathizer.

    There's one and only one way to clean the rot out of our system, and that is to open it up to the sunlight, scrub it out, and disinfect it.

    Your idea - just cover it up and hope no one notices the smell - will only make things worse.
  • Not Stunned
    As I read it, this means that Congress has ceded even MORE power to the executive branch?
  • geraldperdue
    It seems to me that Secretary Gates is using the massacre at Ft. Hood as an excuse to hide the war crimes of the Bush - Cheney administration. It's despicable.
  • disappointedvoter
    Fuck Obama!!!

    He's JUST LIKE BUSH. We don't need any more of that crap.
  • Mooftown
    If you had seen the pictures you would understand why they have been banned....
    they are so brutally fucked up that if they were shown to the world I am sure something horrible would go down

    believe me waterboarding isn't the only thing that went on in guantanamo
  • disappointedvoter
    "if they were shown to the world I am sure something horrible would go down"

    Something horrible already has gone down.

    If you want to prevent future calamities, we MUST admit our crimes and punish the guilty.
  • CharlieL
    Ahh, of course. Because our behavior was so dispicable and inhuman that we might be punished for it, we must be allowed to do it without accountability. It all makes sense now.
  • Mooftown
    No i'm not kidding the pictures are super fucked up horror movie style things. The hatred towards america is already high enough. I don't think it is necessary for anyone to see these photos. It is appalling.

    But I do believe Bush and Cheney should be held accountable and put in prison. Please hold everyone accountable. But if these pictures are released we would very likely have a revolt worldwide against america, regardless of the fact that 99.99% of Americans had nothing to do with these travesties.
  • lorn
    Too bad moofy that average Arabs in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and other nations have been kidnapped and tortured by the thousands for years now.
    Those people and their relatives and their neighbors, and their newspapers and local radio ALL KNOW THIS STUFF.

    So the truth is that only Americans are largely ignorant of the rapes and grizzly torture sessions conducted by Americans on thousands of Arabs. So who are you really hiding the truth from?

    As for your 99% figure, do you cut the Germans of the 1930's-40's the same slack?
  • CharlieL
    The only way the people responsible are held accountable is for EVERYTHING to be made known to EVERYBODY in an open and transparent process.

    Only with the TRUTH out there can JUSTICE be served.
  • lorn
    Oh, so this is the new strategy by Democrats and their information outlets to deal with the ever growing public outrage over PRESIDENT OBAMA and his torture policies.
    Be it protecting Bush and Cheney from investigation and prosecution for torture, his continued endorsement and use of illegal renditions, his talk vs. action on the GITMO closing or his continued efforts to block the torture memos and photos.........Obama has been Bush3 on all things torture.

    But now the spin merchants to the rescue! It is CONGRESS CONGRESS CONGRESS that gave the power to GATES GATES GATES to block the torture photos. Yup that's the way it went down folks......pretty sure the holy man Obama wasn't even in the room, not his decision ya know?
    Obama was probably too busy trying to get health care for Americans or rescuing a baby from a burning building........only his devoted cult of hero worshiping fools would believe that.
    The rest of us know this torture photo cover up is on Obama, no matter how his propaganda outlets try to spin it.
  • edwards_com
    What torture policies did Obama originate. BTW, is health care a 'bad thing' ? Also, can you provide the date eith real proof not a rant as to the President rescuing a child from a burning building?
  • lorn
    http://rawstory.com/08/news/2009/05/07/holder-s...

    http://thehill.com/homenews/administration/6745...

    http://rawstory.com/blog/2009/05/obama-justice-...

    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/21/washington/21...

    Really dude, I could C&P links all day long, but your kool aid induced reality seems to prevent you from accepting facts.
    Just like the Bush lovers felt the warmth of Jesus emanating from W Bush, washing away all of his sins...........so to do the Obama devotees escape the cold realities to basque in his radiance and soothing words.
    Fools.
  • edwards_com
    Once again: Which ones did Obama ORIGINATE not CONTINUE or EXPAND. Also, resorting to your personal insult laced posts make all your works meaningless.
  • lorn
    You play silly word games like a pro, a professional troll.

    My personal insults may make you look stupid, but you don't get to decide what things mean to people. People make those decisions for themselves, and that is quite troubling to right wing fascist swine like you.

    You are a staunch believer that it is OK to EXPAND the Bush doctrine. What a poor pitiful soul you are.
  • edwards_com
    I am glad that I am not you.
    Sincerely
  • Max_1
    A good way to claim innocence...
    ... Hide all evidence of ANY crime.
blog comments powered by Disqus