Reid signals public option may be weakened

By John Byrne
Saturday, November 21st, 2009 -- 8:55 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

miersreid Reid signals public option may be weakenedIn a press conference after the Democrats successfully rounded up enough votes to break a Republican filibuster preventing debate on the party's healthcare overhaul proposal Saturday, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) signaled that members of his caucus are planning to water down the public insurance option originally proposed.

The so-called public option would create a government-run competitor to private insurers in some areas.

Responding to reporters' questions, Reid said: "I welcome [Sen.] Schumer, Landrieu and Carper’s work to get a public option acceptable to all Democrats."

Firedoglake's David Dayen transcribed some of Reid's remarks after the Senate voted to begin debate on the healthcare bill.

Q: [Sens.] Lincoln (D-AR) and Lieberman (I-CT) don’t want a public option, what are you going to do?

Story continues below...

Reid: I welcome Schumer, Landrieu and Carper’s work to get a public option acceptable to all Democrats.

Q: Do you have 60?

Reid: When we have 60 votes, we’ll get it to the President.

Q: What’s that about Landrieu?

Reid: My understanding is that Landrieu said today she’s working with Schumer and Carper to come up with an alternative.

Q: You said Vicki Kennedy called?

Reid: Just a few minutes ago, Vicki Kennedy called after the vote. She was crying pretty hard. We both said that Ted would have been happy. We both felt that he would have been watching.

Q: Is history on your side?

Reid: I’m a student of history. I really do believe that we’re in an historic time in the history of our country. This has been far too long in the making. We’re going to get health care reform. The American people need it and they deserve it. Half of those who file for bankruptcy do it because of health care costs. And half of those people had insurance. So we need to do this.

Dayen notes: "So Reid just confirmed that Chuck Schumer is working with Mary Landrieu and Tom Carper to reach some kind of compromise on the public option that can satisfy everyone in the caucus. The dealmaking has begun. Expect the word “trigger” to come back into the political lexicon any day now."

The trigger option would create a public government-run insurance competitor if and only if insurers failed to meet pre-set criteria -- which liberals say would be caving to the private managed healthcare industry.

Landrieu wrangled $100 million in dedicated aid from Democratic leaders before endorsing a vote on debate over the bill.

"It is clear to me that doing nothing is not an option," Landrieu said.

Sen. Blanche Lincoln (D-AR), the last Democratic holdout to endorse debate, said her vote would "mark the beginning of consideration of this bill by the U.S. Senate, not the end."

Neither Lincoln or Landrieu have endorsed a public option, even though their states are among those with heavy uninsured populations. According to one estimate, nearly one in five residents of Arkansas are uninsured.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • stephhunter
    We must be careful that we don't water down all the benefit of it. We need to make sure that we don't lose sight of how effective it can be! http://cli.gs/z3AtaY/
  • The fact remains that big insurance by refusing care to patients and reimbursement to doctors over typos has ticked everyone off. They have a monopoly over the whole process and a well financed lobby team (including Lieberman's wife) and representatives on both sides of the isle.

    A friend of mine recently laid off just he and his spouse is paying $2,500.00 dollars a month for his COBRA. Health insurance costs more than his mortgage. Anyone taking up the insurance industry's cause doesn't know what they are talking about.

    If you think the insurance companies are going to voluntarily lower their cost while having a monopoly over the process – you are being disingenuous …Over 60% of all US bankruptcies are attributable to medical problems. Most victims are middle class, well educated and have health insurance - (The American Journal of Medicine)

    The insurance companies and their representatives in Congress would love to perpetuate a business model that is crippling our overall economy – a bunch of great Americans aren’t they?

    90% of the wealth concentrated in 1% of the population is no way to run a country but a heck of a way to establish a royalty ruling class. Yacht sales can not sustain 350 million people. I'm for the public option, competition and a level playing field or break up the big insurers like we did AT&T.

    A slavish focus on profit margin might be good for the individual or a business, but it is one helluva lousy way to "govern" a Country. The GOP being a wholly owned subsidiary of Corporate America has a hard time with that concept.


    Paul Burke
    Author-Journey Home
  • McLean, Virginia -- The greedy fanatics have slaughtered millions of people on the altar of their greed. This time they will continue the fight to the death -- of our elderly, children, and disabled.

    May God punish every traitor politician.

    Paul Matthews
  • proudliberal1947
    Why is it Back UP reid can NOT follow through?

    This Clown is forever raising hopes clouding issues and doing massive give aways.

    I say put it on the Line and give fair warning to EVERY DEMOCRATIC Half Stepper, there will be NO double Lip locks on your contributors Zippers, However there will be HELL to pay at the POLLS, you Morons where given the POWER to WORK FOR the PEOPLE NOT your SPECIAL INTEREST. Warning is given, as far as this Half stepping Back up Clown they call Senate Majority Leader I am sorely disappointed he HAS NOT had follow through yet.


    I strongly suggest tieing BIG TAX increases to INSURANCE PROFITS so big it nullifies their PROFITS, ENOUGH with the givew aways.
  • anninaz
    As far as I'm concerned, the more they weaken the public option, the more they need to weaken the mandates. They must pay a price for each incremental attempt to weaken the PO, and to me the most effective price is in the number of new customer that are required to buy the Senators' corporate overlords products. If others think of better or more effective ways to extract a price, all the better, but there must be a cost or they'll just keep cutting until nothing is left. As it stands, the bill might as well be named the Insurance Industry Profit Protection and Enhancement Act!
  • therealjoeschmoe
    Is that a picture of Harry Reid with Harriet Meyers behind him? Say what, RAW?
  • Atilla
    Public option may be weakened? Many Democraps chance of re-election may be weakened too. Who needs Republicans when the criminal corporations have the Blue Dogshit working for them to further destroy this nation? Then, we could talk about the Likud Party's LIEberman, but I have things to do tonight and don't have time to take another shower.
  • truthops2010
    The Democrats are going to succeed in killing any possibility for significant health care reform in our lifetimes. The insurance companies, and big pharma, will see their stocks soar when the final bill is passed and signed by Obama the Great Pretender. ( I just coined that, and I think it fits well…feel free to use it ) Mandating by f'ng FEDERAL LAW that you MUST buy insurance from these private corporations, will secure their monopolistic powers, but now it will be on steroids. I've re-registered as an independent after being a life long Democrat because of the public mandate, and because Obama, and these other Centrist Democrats are indistinguishable from Republicans. Obama's actions behind the scenes with his DOJ speak volumes. For instance, he denounces torture, but makes damn sure, that no one from the Bush Administration has to face any consequences. He has maintained almost every single legal position of the Bush Administration, from torture, to telcos, to asserting even more plenary executive powers than even Bush/Cheney. I think he appointed Dana Perino, to the BBG, just to rub liberal and progressives' faces in it.
  • overdoneputaforkinit
    It is time to burn the bill in a big bonfire and start over.
  • Democratic_Socialist
    Yes, BUT, with single-payer "ON the table". Anything less = unacceptable!
  • nader paul kucinich gravel
    Insurance must profit ~

    We wanted single-payer.
    They sold robust public option.

    Anything else from the DNC is a non-starter scam
  • edwards_com
    Single payer is the only way out just like medicare. Imperfect but no one is perfect except the CREATOR.. Let the malcontents pretend they know better than the CREATOR.t
  • therealjoeschmoe
    Is the CREATOR an insurance company? I'm lost. Oh, you mean "THE" CREATOR? That's a good one. I feel much better now that you brought "god" into it. Just as the conservadems have. I mean, really, why would you need healthcare if you have the CREATOR on your side, right? It's disgusting that legislators are forcing their religious views on the rest of us with their special abortion admendments. Isn't it enough to be bought and paid for by healthcare/pharma?

    Separation of church and state! Separation of lobbyists and state.
  • edwards_com
    Yes, the Creator is a 'good one'. He is perfect for he created all of us, this planet and all things. BTW, GOD is in everything. Not a God of hate or sarcasm, hate, war.My religious beliefs are between me & my Higher Power, the Creator.
    God Bless you
    & Good Luck.
    Sincerely.
  • moxaman
    Unless there is a ROBUST public option that allows anyone to join, the new bill will be a massive give away to the insurance companies. They'll gain 30 million new customers with us taxpayers picking up their bills. Our premiums will escalate and our services will decline. This is a joke people... the democrats are owned lock stock and barrel by the insurance companies. If there is no effective competition (from a public option) then I hope the bill is killed. Enough is enough.
  • dennycrane
    It's not watered down. Since it is not "single-payer", it is like someone pissing on your leg to keep you warm.
blog comments powered by Disqus