American Medical Association rethinking pot prohibition?

By Daniel Tencer
Tuesday, November 10th, 2009 -- 1:05 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

marijuana American Medical Association rethinking pot prohibition?The American Medical Association on Tuesday issued a cautious but historically significant call to change America's marijuana prohibition laws, urging a "review" of the drug's status as a Schedule I drug.

At a meeting in Houston, the AMA's House of Delegates adopted a new policy that calls for "marijuana's status as a federal Schedule I controlled substance be reviewed with the goal of facilitating the conduct of clinical research and development of cannabinoid-based medicines, and alternate delivery methods."

That does not mean the AMA supports the legalization or decriminalization of marijuana.

Schedule I drugs are those considered to have no medical benefit and to be harmful when used under any circumstances. As such, marijuana is currently grouped by the federal government with drugs like heroin and LSD. By comparison, cocaine and methamphetamines are classified as Schedule II drugs, which may have some clinical benefits when used in the proper circumstances. The AMA's stance could simply result in the rescheduling of marijuana as a controlled substance that has some medical benefit.

However, Aaron Houston, director of government relations for the Marijuana Policy Project, calls the move "historic" all the same, noting that it comes from "what has historically been America's most cautious and conservative major medical organization."

Story continues below...

"Marijuana's Schedule I status is not just scientifically untenable, given the wealth of recent data showing it to be both safe and effective for chronic pain and other conditions, but it's been a major obstacle to needed research," he said in a statement.

"It's been 72 years since the AMA has officially recognized that marijuana has both already-demonstrated and future-promising medical utility," said medical student Sunil Aggarwal in a press statement from Americans for Safe Access. Aggarwal has been spearheading the effort by the AMA's youth wing to change the organization's attitude towards marijuana.

ASA government affairs director Caren Woodson pointed out that the American College of Physicians, the country's second-largest medical group, called for a review of marijuana's status last year.

"The two largest physician groups in the US have established medical marijuana as a health care issue that must be addressed," Woodson said. "Both organizations have underscored the need for change by placing patients above politics."

In its report (PDF), the AMA stated:

Results of short term controlled trials indicate that smoked cannabis reduces neuropathic pain, improves appetite and caloric intake especially in patients with reduced muscle mass, and may relieve spasticity and pain in patients with multiple sclerosis. However, the patchwork of state-based systems that have been established for .medical marijuana. is woefully inadequate in establishing even rudimentary safeguards that normally would be applied to the appropriate clinical use of psychoactive substances. The future of cannabinoid-based medicine lies in the rapidly evolving field of botanical drug substance development, as well as the design of molecules that target various aspects of the endocannabinoid system. To the extent that rescheduling marijuana out of Schedule I will benefit this effort, such a move can be supported.

The AMA's move is the latest in a series of small but significant shifts in attitudes towards the liberalization of marijuana policies.

Last month, conservative columnist George F. Will said that the US is "probably in the process" of legalizing marijuana, pointing to the Obama administration's new policy to no longer raid medical marijuana clinics that are legal under state law, so long as those state laws are being observed. (Though one California-based US attorney disputes that there has been any change in policy.)

Additionally, California is currently debating a proposal to decriminalize marijuana. Massachusetts decriminalized marijuana in a state ballot last year.

And recent polls show that support for decriminalization of marijuana has reached a record high in the United States, with some 44 percent of Americans now in favor of reducing or eliminating criminal penalties for possession of the herb.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • Jessi
    These people have their underwears tied so far up their asses, that they cannot think staright. This whole country is ridiculous. You want a solution to this horrible economy?? Legalize marijuana. It's so unbelievably stupid to say its ok to drink alcohol in this country and smoke ciggs but put people in jail for smoking pot. And this 21 and over shit is BULL. C'mon I think even Obama drank in his early years. What makes you think that alcohol AND cigarettes aren't worse than pot? Yet its legal, and I guarantee you that it kills more people in one day than pot will in a year. Pot is no where near those other drugs, anyone that has experienced can tell you themselves. Everyone has their opinion, but this government has everything opposite. They legalize what will kill you, and say hey its illegal to smoke pot. One day, there will be at least one smart person running this whole thing. I have hope....!
  • Hubcap
    THAT'S SOME DANK A** WEED RIGHT THERE INT HAT PICTURE YO!
  • machobongmangoddamn420
    shopped. no herbs that green.
  • conservativeforlife
    Why is everyone saying republicans are evil and shit? Democrats wanted to go to war in 2001 and invade Iraq just like everyone else.
    Keeping marijuana illegal has nothing to do with suppressing minorities either. I dont know how you would come to that. Also ALL opiates, drugs from the coca plant, and hallucinogens are much more dangerous than alcohol. BTW thos are illegal.
    The main reason that weed is illegal is because the govt. would be unable to tax anything but maybe an 8th of whats sold. the rest would be pure profit the govt. didnt even knew existed. They would make no money and look stupid and incompetent.
    Democrats are the ones who made pot illega. FDR was president during that time and he got congress full of his best friends.
  • lloyd
    I dont think some laws should change only the time period that they are from its hard to understand wording of such an how to interpet , i did say to someone a friend of mine that
    it is o.k. to keep things personal because thier is your interpation of laws an others get advice
    from some you know, if its for the AMA an it relates to marijuana most will say you can ask
    if it relates an reading can take awhile if its pages to comprehend ask them if you know or
    need the legal advice go to links you know an uderstand the compassion group under hemp
    laws, nicely written Daniel Tencer P.S. they have a phone number an will get back to you or
    send them a email,which you could already know of the last part an also normal.org to see
    the latest information or talk with some of thier staff , have a good new year in 2010 !
  • sarahpratt
    This is awesome I am glad to hear it!!!!!
  • leapcop
    IT'S ABOUT TIME SINCE THE A.M.A. WAS NEVER CONSULTED WHEN IT WAS MADE ILLEGAL BASED ON "REEFER MADNESS" LIES. BY DEFINITION OF SCHEDULE I, CIGARETTES, ALCOHOL, AND CAFFEINE SHOULD BE SCHEDULE I, NOT CANNABIS!
  • mmjcure
    Its interesting in the 1800's, schedule 1 and 2 drugs took up the majority of the average pharmacies shelf space. Lets think about this carefully for a minute here :)
  • JakeW83
    LSD and psilocybin mushrooms should be legalized as well, as they are in no way harmful, and in some cases they are therapeutic.
  • allenallen
    Hard to get an honest report of the science because the law is tied to the schedule. It makes the law enslaved to the (much simpler) science question.

    It's true. Ask your Senator.

    I realize it is a bigger issue than the strict science on health. However, Congress abdicated their role as lawmakers and they themselves tied the law to the Schedule.

    So.... the lawmakers and the administration have to keep pressuring the FDA to NOT do good science. That's not right for science nor right for the way laws should be enacted.

    The current setup makes fools out of both the FDA and the Senate.
  • i agree
  • john167
    I am a Pharmacist who lost his wife to brain cancer a little over a year ago. I was at an absolute loss on how to alleviate her suffering prior to her diagnosis. She had incredible headaches and nausea and was unable to eat anything outside of popsicles and soup. I called an old friend who brought us some pot. She smiled for the first time in weeks and ate a grilled cheese sandwich. There is absolutely no reason for this to be a schedule 1 drug. I tried every antiemetic and analgesic there is and nothing worked like marijuana.

    And it made her smile.

    What could possibly be illegal about that?
  • davisty
    ummmm Doritos
  • Concerned Parent
    I’m disgusted by the idea that my taxes are spent arresting marijuana users while violent criminals roam free, and I’m sick of the idea that the criminal drug cartels might try to get my kids involved in drugs just for the money.
    Licensing, taxing, and regulating the distribution of marijuana is the surest way to put the criminal drug dealers out of business and protect our children from the money-hungry criminal element. It’s time to protect our children and take the marijuana business out of the hands of criminals. License, tax, and regulate the marijuana business.
    And while we’re at it, let’s find a way to pull the revenue-hungry public policy in the right direction on personal cultivation (i.e., let’s get past the “you can’t tax it because people will just grow their own” argument). Let’s implement a personal cultivation permit. Limit the size of the growing area or the number of plants, and put a small user-fee on it to cover administrative costs, something like a fishing license. Maybe high enough that there will be a little something left over for education or fixing the roads.
    One possibility:$100 per year for a permit to cultivate a dozen plants.
    It’s a win-win.
  • Savantster
    .
    "Let’s implement a personal cultivation permit."

    Then you should implement a personal grower's fee for gardens, too.. and start charging people for making their own alcohol. And if people knit clothes, charge them for that, too..

    no, you don't charge people for being self sufficient.. you don't charge people for just living their lives.. The licensing and fees for hunting and fishing are because individuals are taking public resources and those resources need to be managed.. no one needs to manage my back yard but me. If I want to toss out 10 seeds, that's my business.

    The only thing that even remotely makes sense is that since we want to keep it away from children, a statute could be drafted that says the plants must be grown in a secure enclosure, such as a home or greenhouse. That's about it..
    .
  • It will be an event welcomed globally if the US government remedies its stance on marijuana. The rest of the civilized world has already legalized cannabis and have in many countries begun serious research efforts to glean the remarkable medical benefits from a plant that has sent hundreds and hundreds of thousands of innocent people to prison in the United States alone.

    Thank you, finally AMA, for attempting to rectify your grievous error of 1937 when you did the exact opposite and recommend to congress to make the plant illegal.
  • RFWoodstock
    Valid medicinal value, it’s a victimless crime, the War on Drugs WAY too costly, too many arrests for simple possession, tax it and use the money to pay for health insurance and to reduce the deficit…Need I say more?

    Woodstock Universe supports legalization of Marijuana.

    We will giveaway a Woodstock Universe Prize Package to the best member blog on “Why we should legalize marijuana?”

    Prize package includes Woodstock Universe T-shirt and magnet, WDST decal, Radio Woodstock Live in Woodstock CD and Woodstock 3 days of peace and music Director’s Cut DVD.

    Join Woodstock Universe to blog.
    Add your vote in our poll about legalization at http://www.woodstockuniverse.com.

    Current poll results…97% for legalization, 3% against.

    Peace, love, music, one world,
    RFWoodstock
  • Independentgal
    Legalize it, tax it and pay for REAL healthcare reform with the proceeds.

    What's so hard about that?
  • Any soldier that picks up a Heroin addiction in Afghanistan should be considered disabled and discharged under honorable conditions. Upon release most vets will continue their habit, many get arrested and are imprisoned. It would be best if their Heroin habit was supported by a V.A. hospital. There they would be given the drug to take home and inject. This humane program would help keep our drug addicted vets out of prison. Those that want to kick the habit will have the opportunity. A 24/7 drug counselor should be made available.
  • kayttt2000
    If you think there doing this for the right reasons,,think again..

    When one rat is cornered by the law, they step down,,
    When a pack of rats are cornered by the law, they do PR..

    The AMA is a pack of rats,,
    They are SO guilty of SO many things,,,

    This agency was formed to protect profits of said individuals and companies..
    They are guilty of blocking advancements of MANY Medical Sciences that has set back the Medical Industry, decades...
    I hope they share a cell with the men they helped for profit!
  • I love obama
    Yeah, and I could right now buy a gallon of vodka and die of alcohol poisoning but that has medical benefits because its a schedule 1 drug, or NOT! How do these fucking idiots come up with these laws. obviously everything they make up is based on capitalism since alcohol would make more money against marijuana if both were legal. Pot would completely destroy both the alcohol industry and the tobacco industry if people could smoke and get high.
  • yvonneo
    But you see, alcohol has the added benefit of causing people to have long, drawn out illnesses that increase the profits of the pharmas and healthcare business interests, and pot does not.
  • Phil E. Drifter
    "Quit Smoking in 7 Days - Enough is enough. Kick Addiciton in a Week Guranteed. Get Started Now! - CigaCease.com"

    Call me crazy, but I'm not going to trust any advertisement that has 2 words spelled wrong,

    Not to mention, I quit smoking in 1 day. Or less, I suppose. I finished my pack of smokes watching the Phillies lose game 6 of the world series, and I'd already decided $6/pack was too much to be paying someone to kill me slowly anyway, so I just stopped buying them.

    It's really not difficult, you just have to truly want to quit, then it's no problem. The biggest problem is that TOBACCO IS AVAILABLE EVERYWHERE!
  • This very good news for those who use marijuana, which been clinically proven to posses medicinal benefits to so many who suffer a variety of ailments. It can also be very helpful in quitting a cigarette habit. Let compassion for those it gives relief to take precedence over politics and antiquated propaganda.
  • revraygreen
    BRING IT !!!!!!!
  • rxgary
    heres how to end the useless war of terror or against it or whatever. for the price of 1 years department of the motherland or homeland security or whatever fascist name you give it, we could buy every adult american a handgun , gun safety class and self defense class. war won
  • bigdog1271
    Any doctor that tell you Marijuana is dangerous under any circumstances, is a quack who should lose his license.
  • zelduh
    Let's stop lying about pot. It is MUCH LESS DANGEROUS than alcohol. (Have you ever seen a ward in a hospital for pot heads? You certainly see them for alcoholics!)

    Pot should simply be legalized, taxed and sold in liquor stores to people who are of the "legal age;" right next to the beer and wine.
  • zelduh
    BTW I don't smoke pot (I don't drink beer either.) I am just being honest. The time has come for society - and politicians - to be honest about it too.
  • Independentgal
    I don't smoke it, either, but I couldn't agree more with your posts. The tax revenue just might go a long way toward paying for a GOOD healthcare system.
  • Phil E. Drifter
    The AMA has ALWAYS supported medicinal cannabis, one of their doctors appeared in Congress to give testimony on that historic day in 1937 when 'marijuana' was outlawed.

    Directly from tinyurl.com/1mn (which is a transcript of the speech given by Dr. Whitebread in front of the CA Judges' Association before the historic 1995 vote on Prop 215):

    The other piece of medical testimony came from a man named Dr. William C. Woodward. Dr. Woodward was both a lawyer and a doctor and he was Chief Counsel to the American Medical Association. Dr. Woodward came to testify at the behest of the American Medical Association saying, and I quote, "The American Medical Association knows of no evidence that marihuana is a dangerous drug."

    What's amazing is not whether that's true or not. What's amazing is what the Congressmen then said to him. Immediately upon his saying, and I quote again, "The American Medical Association knows of no evidence that marihuana is a dangerous drug.", one of the Congressmen said, "Doctor, if you can't say something good about what we are trying to do, why don't you go home?"
  • bobofat
    God made weed and some asshole made Texas.
  • bobofat
    If the troops smoked weed they might not all be such douche bags...Wait...I think saying f the troops isnt a brillant idea. Have you any idea how many go around shooting up places. More to come if America cant let them get stoned. That would curb PTSD in a real way...Instead they are pumped full of pfizer and bayer...The same drugs whose flashy ads say theres a risk of suicide associated with their use??? WTF? No...I think troops are our Sons, Daughters, Sisters, Brothers, Mothers, Fathers, Nieces, Uncles, Aunts,Nephews,Grandparents, friends and Nieghbors...And anything else you can think of so Im not at all surprised by the reaction people have when we disregard that fact...The reaction by the United Stupids of America is typical and we shouldnt forget who sends our loved ones to war...Gay Republicans who are too afraid to come out...bastards, and an occasional puck here or there playing the devils advocate.

    Again...PTSD+POT=REAL RESULTS.
  • jdouglas
    Regular marijuana use effectively kills the God Virus. Without an infected population, the Bastards would no longer have religion as a tool to manipulate the Idiots into fighting and supporting their wars. The only recognizable benefit to the Bastards, might be a population that is slightly more susceptible to subliminal commercial TV messages. So, the real question for the Bastards is this: Has the general understanding and acceptance of modern science already rendered the God Virus sufficiently impotent to warrant its abandonment as a device of social control? And, if so, can TV programming take up the slack?
  • kucinich2012
    Y'wanna pass that over here next?
  • Satan
    Paying taxes for weed I smoke only to see half of it being spent on the U.S. war machine in a nation where so few are actively opposed to endless war is something that's not going to happen with me.

    Tax the watching of Pro Football, I'm sure it does much more damage to society in the long run, oh yeah, and fuck the troops too.
  • You better have been trying to make some stupid point when your typed "fuck the troops"!
  • Savantster
    .
    There is no tax on alcohol you brew/ferment yourself, there is only a tax for selling it.. as in, you pay a tax for making the profit. If cannabis is legalized, and it should be, then there would likely not be a tax on personally grown/smoked dope.. only stuff you sell to the lazy people. nothing wrong with that.

    and if cannabis becomes legal, we'll probably have a hard time engaging in those illegal wars because soldiers will start to "wake up" and won't want to be there.

    and since Pro Football has TONS of novelties sold in association of it, it already produces a lot of tax revenue in sales taxes. Hell, i have to pay sales tax on my cable bill, so I'm already paying taxes just to watch stuff.

    And be nice to the troops.. it wasn't troops (or even ex-troops) that got us into this war.. most of these soldiers aren't really all that bright (hence being in the military) and bought the lies sold to them.. and now they are just following orders, thinking they are making us safe over here by fighting them over there. At least, most troops.. some are just douche bags, fuck those ones..
  • Savantster
    .
    And doesn't it figure this is being pushed as "so we can make cannabanoid drugs"? WTF?! smoke it! inhaler it! eat it!.. study to make synth drugs or extracts.. proooo. put the middle man in just to make profits?

    LEGALIZE IT already.. sheesh.
    .
  • harlinredlands
    What kind of mindless, corrupt, authoritarian, worthless piece of flesh.... would want to KEEP Marijuana as a Schedule 1 Drug?

    Religious-Militant-Republicans and Stupid Follower Democrats, that's who
blog comments powered by Disqus