Again: Fox News uses old footage, makes Palin book tour look bigger

By Daniel Tencer
Wednesday, November 18th, 2009 -- 9:30 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

palinfoxnewsbogusfootage Again: Fox News uses old footage, makes Palin book tour look biggerUpdate at bottom: Fox News apologizes for airing wrong footage

Fox News was barely done licking its wounds from last week's embarrassing revelations that it had used old footage to make a Tea Party protest look bigger than it was, and now the network stands accused of doing the same thing again.

During a Happening Now segment Wednesday, anchor Gregg Jarrett described "huge crowds" showing up to a Sarah Palin book tour event, and showed footage he described as "just coming in to us now" showing the former Alaska governor surrounded by adoring crowds.

But, as Faiz Shakir at ThinkProgress reported, the images the network ran "appeared to be old file footage of Palin rallies from the 2008 presidential campaign."

Media watchdog MediaMatters soon confirmed the report, displaying a screenshot of Fox's footage from Wednesday's broadcast with a nearly identical image from a Palin rally in Ocala, Florida, shortly before last year's election.

Story continues below...

While critics of Fox News will surely jump on this as further evidence that the network acts as a promotion tool for Republican politicians, network execs immediately declared that the incident was an innocent mix-up.

"This was a production error in which the copy editor changed a script and didn't alert the control room to update the video,'' senior vice-president Michael Clemente told the Chicago Tribune's Swamp Politics blog. "There will be an on-air explanation during Happening Now on Thursday."

Media observers pointed out that despite Jarrett's claim that the footage was "just coming in to us now," the mix-up may well have been unintended.

"This appears to be little more than a momentary disconnect between newsreader and news producer than a conscious attempt to mislead," writes Jason Linkins at the Huffington Post. "Of course, the fact that Fox was caught manipulating footage in a misleading manner is only going to spur further suspicions when things like this happen."

Last week, Fox News anchor Sean Hannity apologized to viewers after Comedy Central's Daily Show slammed the network for using footage of a Sept. 12 Tea Party rally in Washington evidently to make a Nov. 5 anti-health reform rally look bigger.

"Although it pains me to say this, Jon Stewart, Comedy Central -- he was right," Hannity said.

At that Sept. 12 rally, Fox News was caught stage-managing a crowd, with an off-camera producer waving instructions to chanting protesters.

Swamp Politics reports that this latest incident could result in firings at the network. "It's highly like[ly] that serious disciplinary action will be taken for those responsible behind the scenes in the control room," the blog reports. "News executives there consider this to have been a sloppy and unnecessary error."

The following video was broadcast on Fox News Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2009, and upoaded to the Web by ThinkProgress.

In a 30-second statement, Fox News anchor Jane Skinner apologized Thursday for airing the wrong footage while teasing a segment about crowds outside a Sarah Palin book signing.

Yesterday we told you about Sarah Palin kicking off her book tour, and then we spoke to Sean Hannity about an interview he did former Governor Palin. When introducing this segment, we showed you footage of people lining up in Michigan for a book signing that evening. In the tease before the segment -- to tease to commercial, we told you how those people were already lining up to meet palin. The problem is we didn't show you the video that we were actually referencing. Instead, we mistakenly aired what's called file tape of Sarah Palin. We didn't mean to mislead anybody in that tease. It was a mistake, and for that, we apologize.

This video is from Fox News' Happening Now, broadcast Nov. 19, 2009.


Download video via RawReplay.com

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • Nickelthrower
    Greetings,

    I work in the corporate media business and what Fox described was 100% impossible. Editors can not just send whatever video they choose and all footage is specifically time coded. There is a Technical Director that runs the production side of every show and this person would have to specifically request archival footage in advance because our "decks" just do not have storage to hold everything forever.

    Fox LIed.
  • habu99
    Yes, funny how contemporary footage gets somehow confused with dated campaign footage over a year old. Also funny how Faux "news" gaffes always involve making the right-wing teabagger movement look bigger/better, never smaller.
  • Stephen Martin
    If Fox is a vigilant as they say they are then, both statements cannot be true. Meaning: How could they say this was an "honest mistake" and still say they are top of things in the newsroom? You can't have it both ways FOX.
    CAUGHT in a lie....again. This is just the video end. Their news scripts are filled with couched falsehoods and misinformation. Unfortunately they cater to a viewership that doesn't know any better or simply doesn't read the news. At a time when so much is available, we're talking LAZY. Lazy, stupid people. Cattle.
  • allenallen
    It's like the old USSR era propaganda. They should always be titled thus:

    Fox News [sic].

    Folks, if you watch any of Murdock's channels or any of his media... you need to stop. Because you are helping this to happen. Easy to avoid, for starters just turn off anything that says 'Fox.'
  • GunTotinLiberal
    If we are to believe that mixing up file footage, incorrectly identifying scandal plagued Republicans as Dems and that thing about The Paris Business Review are all “innocent mistakes” we can only draw one conclusion. The people that work behind the scenes at Fox are the dumbest most incompetent bunch of dolts that ever walked the earth. Of course a more reasonable explanation is they are doing this all on purpose.
  • Spiffarino
    Intentional or not, pressure from organizations like Media Matters, pundits like Maddow and Olbermann, and pundo-comics like Jon Stewart are preventing Faux News from manipulating their credulous viewers as much as they otherwise would.

    Every time they do this, they need to have the Howling Left (of which I'm a proud member) all over their asses. Don't give them a freakin' inch.
  • NotConvinced
    It's getting to the point where calling out Fox on their BS is like making fun of retarded kids. There's going to be a backlash from hillbillies and imbeciles that the MSM is piling on. Look at the Fox stars, Beck, O'Dickhead, Innanitty, they are giving everything they have and still come up short. When will the world quit picking on them. Sure they're complete idiots but it's not their fault. They are just playing the hand they were dealt.
  • kiboshki
    .
    Good point. To all those out there who moan "this isn't news", Spiffarino's comment is exactly the reason it needs to get out there.

    The more that intelligent folks howl about the mis-information campaign perpetuated by FOX News and their ilk, the more likely it is that at least a few regular FOX watchers will get the message that their information source is corrupt to the core - or at least get fed slightly less harmful and mind-numbing crap.
    .
  • George_of_the_Jungle
    In 1993, Arafat signed the Oslo peace accords with Israel. A year later, he was allowed to return to his native homeland back from exile. So, on 9/11 Fox Noise used footage from the celebrations that took place in 1994 upon the arrival of Arafat back in the West Bank. That footage was used to claim that Palestinians were celebrating in the streets for what happened on 9/11. It was the same fabrication seen here.

    For the life of me I don't understand how Fox's manipulation of these things is legal.
  • Savantster
    .
    It's "legal" because corporations are "people" in America, and "people" have free speech. So, corporations can say what they want to..

    I just wonder how long before the "truth in advertising" laws are shot down by the SCOTUS since you're obstructing their free speech when you don't let them make claims that are unsubstantiated. Hell, if we're going to let them flat out buy politicians under the free speech guise soon, consumer protections will go away next.. just watch..
  • damixaustex
    Take a look at how they fueled the race debate after the 2008 election.
  • EyesWide Open
    Fow news is the equivalent of the trashy skank who stuffs her bra.Or how about the douche that crams a rolled up sock down the front of his pants. SO...Fox News likes to stuff their junk...just like the skanks and douche bags they are.
  • I've set up a page that can be a simple index for future "incidents" on Fox News - and will gladly add for other news stations too.

    http://poorrobertsalmanac.wordpress.com/waching...

    Once is a mistake. Twice is a pattern.
  • damixaustex
    It's all day long, every day. I hope you have a lot of storage space.

    Seriously, my partner watches it every morning for entertainment...to see what todays BS story line will be. Watch the scroll and the imagery and listen to what they say.
    It's scripted, alright. Take a look back at the Acorn reporting. It was especially obvious then.
  • PieWackett
    Lovely! Just Google 'Fox News Error' I'm sure you will just dance with the huge returns!
  • douvie
    Why don't they just drop all pretense and show footage from V-J Day on Broadway, 1945. Who'll notice.
  • GunTotinLiberal
    Given the average and rather advanced age of your typical Fox viewer, there is a risk they would see themselves in such footage.
  • Mooftown
    you can see the stupid country first sign for the mccain campaign in the background, what a blatant obvious ridiculous lie .... it doesn't make any sense
  • jimbo701
    It makes perfect sense when you take into account the intellectual level of the average FOX Nausea viewer
  • And Hannity just apologized days ago for doctoring the Bachmann Tea Party footage.
blog comments powered by Disqus