AFP: ‘Outrage’ in Washington over Obama’s Japan bow

By Agence France-Presse
Monday, November 16th, 2009 -- 1:43 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

obamaakihitomichiko AFP: Outrage in Washington over Obamas Japan bowNews photos of President Barack Obama bowing to Japan's emperor have incensed critics here, who said the US leader should stand tall when representing America overseas.

Obama on Monday was in China, having wrapped up the Japan leg of his Asia trip two days earlier. But Washington's punditocracy was still weighing whether or not the US president had disgraced his country two days earlier by having taken a deep bow at the waist while meeting Japan's Emperor Akihito.

Obama isn't the first American president to do so. Back in the 1980s, Republican president Ronald Reagan was criticized after bowing to Queen Elizabeth the first time he met her, and President George W. Bush bowed before Saudi Arabia's king while being presented with a medal.

Political talk shows have played and replayed the moment from the second day of Obama's week-long Asia tour, which set the blogosphere on fire and chat show tongues wagging.

"I don't know why President Obama thought that was appropriate. Maybe he thought it would play well in Japan. But it's not appropriate for an American president to bow to a foreign one," said conservative pundit William Kristol speaking on the Fox News Sunday program, adding that the gesture bespoke a United States that has become weak and overly-deferential under Obama.

Story continues below...

Another conservative voice, Bill Bennett, said on CNN's "State of the Union" program: "It's ugly. I don't want to see it."

"We don't defer to emperors. We don't defer to kings or emperors. The president of the United States -- this coupled with so many apologies from the United States -- is just another thing," said Bennett.

Some conservative critics juxtaposed the image of Obama with one of former US vice president Dick Cheney, who greeted the emperor in 2007 with a firm handshake but no bow.

"I'll bet if you look at pictures of world leaders over 20 years meeting the emperor in Japan, they don't bow," Kristol said.

Some said the gesture was particularly grating coming after Obama's bow to Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah at a G20 meeting in April.

The US president's Asia trip comes just over a year after he won election to the White House, and is designed to shore up US power in a region increasingly dominated by rising giant China.

But back home, Obama's bow in Japan seems to have grabbed much of the attention being paid to the trip.

The gesture appears to have touched a particularly raw nerve among Obama critics who said the president has hastened America's decline as a world superpower by being too apologetic and too deferential in his dealings with other world leaders.

While most of the commentary about the bow in Japan was decidedly negative, some political observers, like longtime Democratic activist Donna Brazile, came to the president's defense.

"I think it's a gesture of kindness," she told CNN, adding that the bow appeared intended to show "goodwill between two nations that respect each other."

Meanwhile, an unnamed, senior Obama administration official told the Politico.com news site that the president had simply been observing protocol.

"I think that those who try to politicize those things are just way, way, way off base," the official told Politico.

"I don't think anybody who was in Japan -- who saw his speech and the reaction to it, certainly those who witnessed his bilateral meetings there -- would say anything other than that he enhanced both the position and the status of the US, relative to Japan," Politico wrote.

"It was a good, positive visit at an important time, because there's a lot going on in Japan."

(with additional reporting)

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • dolly lanna
    Showing respect will make us respected in the world. Those idiots who claim superior attitudes and guns show how great we are, are the same kind that got this world into this mess. What ignorant fools they are.
  • Midlife Mediterranean
    Indeed. And where was their outrage when Dubya horribly lost face by puking into the lap of the Japanese prime minister? Or do they think that was the better way to represent the US?
  • lousgirl84
    I don't remember that. I remember his father passing out during some foreign trip
  • stellans
    I think that was Dubya's father.
  • hippie1367
    At least he isn't holding a saudi's hand!
  • lousgirl84
    Or jacking him off (LOL)
  • Sage
    The fact that Obama is bowing to the emperor of Japan is not a sign of weakness, in Japan it is a sign of respect. If you bow to someone, it can also mean expressing your gratitude for their care. We should be happy that Obama is trying to make strong connections with outside countries, including their formalities. Not bowing in Japan to someone of that position is considered rude, so I personally respect Obama more due to the fact that he's taking other countries' customs into consideration. Instead of worrying about America's ego, we should be more focused on our attempt to better our foreign relations. We are the melting pot of the world, so why are we still having problems accepting diversity?
  • Oh god, have these idiots never been out of their own back yard. Before I go to another country I study the customs so as not to appear rude. I've been to Japan, bowing is done everywhere and in every circumstance. I remember getting on an elevator full of strangers and they all gave me a little bow, and I returned it. Sheesh I'm sure Obama knows what to do in a foreign culture better than these ignoramuses who criticize him. sheesh.
  • CarlCampos
    "Outrage?"

    The conservative quotes in this article are "whining."

    If you want to see outrage, look back at the photos of George W. Bush kissing and holding hands with the Saudi dictators.
  • dennycrane
    Gee, how about the war criminal "Rummy-killing-Fields" rumsfeld shaking hands with "Whos-Sane" when he sold the shit to kill the Kurds? How about bush kissing the saudis?
  • grtpyrmd
    Looks like a mutual bow of respect, a Japanese custom. The frothing right wing rabid rabble will say anything, anytime to undermine this president. They are spoiling for a shooting war.
  • tjfxh
    Obama probably did it as much because he knew conservative's head would explode as to influence the Japanese people by showing deep respect for them through the symbol of the emperor as head of state. Americans who know little of Japan cannot realize what an effect with will have in Japan. Showing respect is absolutely huge in the Orient and Japan in particular. Older Japanese men used bow to each other with heads almost to the floor when I was in Japan in the Sixties. Traditionalists probably still do.

    Diplomatically, it was a brilliant move that will pay off big. Totally different from Bush's cowboy arrogance that insulted everyone and destroyed America's image as respectful partner instead of a warlord.
  • airjackie
    Washington seems to have no problem with President's Bush, Bush and Reagan bowing to Japanese/Chinese President during their terms. I guess those Republican Presidents were showing respect as US Leaders. Now that President Obama is showing the same respect it seems to be wrong. We watched President GW Bush welcome his friend the former Japanese President to the White House as Bush bowed. Now I will admit Cheney rushed when summoned by the Saudi King during Thanksgiving. It was to funny as the Saudi King ordered Cheney to his country right now. Cheney announced he would go after Thanksgiving, but the Saudi King ordered him there right now and didn't care that the next day was Thanksgiving. Yes like a good dog Cheney quickly took a plane to make sure he got there as ordered.
  • AlohaTexYorker
    OMG. How stupid are conservatives? I've lived in Japan for 4 years. Everyone bows in Japan no matter what their position. Its like shaking hands in Japan. This is equivalent to conservatives complaining that he shook the emporer's hand. Not bowing to the emporer would be kind of a diss. Its would be like leaving someone hanging on a high-five. Conservatives must think America is an extremely fragile and weak country if our president bowing in Japan is a sign of the decline of our super power status. Its good policy to observe foreign cultural practices in foreign countries. It doesn't harm America at all. People are so freaking stupid.
  • mcc
    there is a fight going on everywhere...us againest them... only when we rise above and see we are one will the wars stop and the healing begin... fox is there to create chaos plan and simple...
  • roland99
    War-mongering, 100%-wrong, crazed-loon Bill Kristol is relevant how exactly?
  • xxxevilgrinxxx
    To go to another country where bowing is the custom and not bow? The rudeness of that gesture speaks for itself, doesn't it? Not that I think the bow is really the issue at all. If he didn't bow, the right wingers would be apoplectic about Obama's terrible manners and what that means for the US too. It has nothing to do with the gesture, but with wingnuts looking for anything to complain about. It's good to know that at least Obama has good manners; I'd hate to think of what McCain or, the gods forbid, Palin, would do if they ended up in Japan, but I'm sure their followers would think they'd done a great thing through the insult.
  • Tommy Dunes
    This is just more Freedom Fries bullshit from America's backwoods contingent.
  • sag801
    Exactly! Showing respect for other culture allows for us to establish respect from other culture. I do not want to be the centric ugly American that thinks we are the only one that exist in this world, and that our culture is superior to everyone else. That we have some kind of superiority complex that we to constantly prove that we are bigger and badder than everyone else. That was our mentality for the last 8 years and look at where it has gotten us!
  • chabuka
    I was more offended by Bush's kiss and hand-holding of the Saudi Prince...fifteen of the nineteen 9/11 hijackers were Saudi citizens ...and Saudi is where the OPEC cartel resides.... OPEC's oil price gouging and market manipulation thats got the price of gas back up to about 3.25 a gal.............and the morons on the right are outraged about a sign of respect shown to Japan, from an American President...? They are really just outraged about the fact that Obama is a Democrat and half Afro-American...such pitiful, frightened little white men the "right" has as its "leaders"...
blog comments powered by Disqus