ACORN sues Congress for defunding it; Group says Congress bowed to Fox News

By Raw Story
Thursday, November 12th, 2009 -- 11:12 am
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

acorn logo1 ACORN sues Congress for defunding it; Group says Congress bowed to Fox NewsThe community organizing group ACORN, recently walloped by conservative activists who posed as a prostitute and a pimp and tried to get employees to incriminate themselves, is suing Congress for defunding its organization.

The group has teamed with the Center for Constitutional Rights, who has filed suit on their behalf. It argues that Congress' move infringed on their Fifth Amendment right to due process, and their First Amendment right to freedom of association.

The complaint was filed this morning in the U.S. District Court of New York.

From a release issued to RAW STORY:

Today, the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) filed a case challenging Congress’s unconstitutional defunding of the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now (ACORN). The case charges Congress with violating the Bill of Attainder provision in the U.S. Constitution, violating the Fifth Amendment right to due process, and infringing on the First Amendment right to freedom of association by targeting affiliated and allied organizations, as well.

Story continues below...

CCR attorneys say members of Congress violated the Constitution by declaring an organization guilty of a crime and punishing it and its members without benefit of a trial.

Said CCR Cooperating Attorney Jules Lobel, “It's not the job of Congress to be the judge, jury, and executioner. We have due process in this country, and our Constitution forbids lawmakers from singling out a person or group for punishment without a fair investigation and trial. Congress, as well as individuals and organizations must abide by the rule of law.”

The lawsuit seeks a temporary restraining order to prevent the government from reallocating funds designated for the organization and its affiliates and a preliminary injunction to stop Congress from singling out a single organization for punishment without proper investigation or due process.

The plaintiffs are ACORN, the ACORN Institute, and the New York ACORN Housing Company. The suit is ACORN v. USA and was filed in federal court in the Eastern District of New York.

CCR Legal Director Bill Quigley said, “It is outrageous to see Congress violating the Constitution for purposes of political grandstanding. With all the crimes and infractions committed by banks, pharmaceutical companies, and private government contractors, they have been rewarded with bailouts, tax credits, and billions of dollars in new contracts. Congress bowed to FOX News and joined in the scapegoating of an organization that helps average Americans going through hard times to get homes, pay their taxes, and vote. Shame on them.”

Since the vote to temporarily ban all federal funds from ACORN and its affiliates, related organizations have suffered. For example, in an affidavit filed in today’s lawsuit, an ACORN affiliate wholly separate from the national organization charges it has been unfairly affected. The organization, ACORN Institute (AI), had grants pending to provide computer training, asthma education, tax preparation, and GED classes, among other programs.

The affidavit avers that no grant the organization has received and administrated “has ever even allegedly involved any misconduct, misappropriation, fraud or other illegal conduct. AI has never been indicted nor convicted of any crime, nor … has any AI employee ever been indicted or convicted of a crime in conjunction with any work they have done for AI. AI has never been denied any grant from any federal agency due to fraud or other alleged misconduct.”

The Center for Constitutional Rights is dedicated to advancing and protecting the rights guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Founded in 1966 by attorneys who represented civil rights movements in the South, CCR is a non-profit legal and educational organization committed to the creative use of law as a positive force for social change. Visit www.ccrjustice.org.

Talking Points Memo's Zachary Roth has more. He notes that after the bill was passed, "Critics of the bill immediately argued that it was unconstitutional, thanks to the Constitution's prohibition on bills of attainder. The courts have long held unconstitutional any acts of Congress that apply either to specific individuals, or to easily ascertainable members of a group, in order to punish them without a trial."

ACORN's suit isn't Congress' only problem.

In September, RAW STORY noted that overly-broad language used by lawmakers intending to pull government funding for community organizing group ACORN could have the unintended effect of forcing the government to also pull funds from much of the military-industrial complex.

"The congressional legislation intended to defund ACORN, passed with broad bipartisan support, is written so broadly that it applies to 'any organization' that has been charged with breaking federal or state election laws, lobbying disclosure laws, campaign finance laws or filing fraudulent paperwork with any federal or state agency. It also applies to any of the employees, contractors or other folks affiliated with a group charged with any of those things," wrote Huffington Post reporter Ryan Grimm.

"In other words, the bill could plausibly defund the entire military-industrial complex. Whoops."

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • killscumtraitors
    acorn scum are traitors criminals democrats communinists blacks muslims jews..hispanics...the criminal scum underworld that gave us the democrat scum stolen votes..a little zyklon-b into their headquarters would be a great thing
  • TaterSalad
    Hey, Acorn is a great start. I hope it doesn't end there!
  • TaterSalad
  • Low Road to High Finance: McClatchy Expose Reveals How Goldman Sachs Sold Off Billions in Mortgage Securities After Anticipating Housing Collapse

    GREG GORDON: Aninger and Toy said they appealed to their superiors to reject shaky loans in which lenders had required no verification.

    MELISSA TOY: At times, I didn’t understand why we were even working, because they were overriding our decisions. Or if we question anything, if we tried to decline a loan, they were going beyond us and approving them.

    http://www.democracynow.org/2009/11/4/sachs

    McClatchy: How Goldman secretly bet on the U.S. housing crash

    http://www.mcclatchydc.com/227/story/77791.html...

    McClatchy: Goldman takes on new role: taking away people's homes

    http://www.mcclatchydc.com/227/story/77841.html

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DIe99r6Qts&feat...

    http://www.democracynow.org/2009/11/4/sachs
  • TaterSalad
    Acorn should be indicted under the R.I.C.O. statute as an on-going criminal enterprise!
  • So should KBR and many others way worse than ACORN. Don't you agree? Or only ACORN. Is it because they're black?
  • TaterSalad
    Good luck with the lawsuit. LOL. I'd like to read all the comments but FOX News just came on and I got to go.
  • Praxman
    Ok two points on this...

    1) an observation...is it my imagination but twenty years ago would this 'dirty trick' be a FBI ops to entrap a few, parade them in front of a court, jail them and then have the 'echo machine' would simply discredit the organization and hope that people distrust it enough to disrupt it's funding stream. In the Noughties, this type of thing has become a formal part of the Corporate State and done with the stated intent of eliminating it completely without the ideological incrementalism.

    2) It's become obvious, except to the hard core partisan, that the Ds and Rs are the same. Given that the dems are -- well to be kind RINOs with a charismatic figurehead puppet that will do little more than hang out, like Clinton did, move the goalposts to the far right and play the populist victim card directly to the media. Problem of course is that NOBODY is buying this crap anymore and an outfit like ACORN with it's organizing clout is obviously MORE of a liability and threat to sitting Ds because of the type of districts both ACORN and the dems hold.

    It wouldn't do having an voter organization that vested a LOT in the Obama debacle to feel cheated by Ds, especially on health care, and actively organize against those millionaire scum that betrayed the 'hope'. That's why it was important to eliminate them before the primary season.

    It wasn't the GOP, it was the DEMs...Murdoch's assets are guns for hire. It don't matter whether it be commie china to support the reformists! over the hard-liners or what appears to be, if the convictions in the UK are a glimpse into his racket, a quasi-privately run INTEL operation that has no qualms engaging in break-ins, thefts, wiretaps of prominent people by so-called journalists.
  • morepatience
    Didn't ACORN state that the money they receive from Congress is a drop in the bucket compared to their other contributors? ACORN is definitely not high-minded enough to go after Congress on principal alone.

    Maybe while they are in court it can finally be legally shown that all of their various entities are not wholly separate as they would like everyone to believe.
  • Brett
    I hope ACORN wins, but I hope even more that the entire military-industrial complex is defunded as suggested in the last sentence of the article.
  • Wildcat
    "It argues that Congress' move infringed on their Fifth Amendment right to due process, and their First Amendment right to freedom of association."

    Please take note of this argument. As soon as John Roberts and his Supreme Court rules that corporations DO enjoy the same rights under the Constitution that were only intended for living, breathing human beings, feel free to RUB THIS IN THE FACE of any and every Reich-winger you encounter.
  • great!
  • If I had to choose to sacrifice ACORN and at the same time defund the Industrial Military Complex and the Mercenaries like Blackwater and KBR then I could live with that.
    Unfortunately it is never going to happen. The cancer of of the IMC and the mercenary organisations have a death grip on the Republic that Congress don't have the will or the balls to break. In truth organisations like ACORN for all its faults are the best hope. They terrify FOX and the corrupt of both parties.
  • dennycrane
    Where is Morris Dees? We'll see "who's your daddy."
  • Talis13
    Go get those ignorant cons and the dems that allowed this to happen.
  • Well at last, the Dems should never had went along with this, every business has bad apples and ACORN has helped thousands through the years, they have my support.
  • wallacewpancoast
    This is an example of the supine government we are saddled with. Because some nut alleges criminal activity is no cue to omit evidence of the alleged crime. I, for one, would like to see more action on the bidless contractors who DO break the law. THIS IS FAR MORE NECESSARY. Sometimes it would be pleasing to think that government judgemrnts DO have rationality. THat is a new concept I expect!
  • bowen
    I Doubt ACORN can win this case, Raw Story itself stated how the broad language of the bill allows for any group to be defunded. Obviously this was written in that specific way to avoid the "bill of attainder" clause The real test will be if congress will stand by its word and defund Dyncorp, Halliburton, KBR, and Blackwater (Xe). Of course I wont hold my breath.

    I wouldn't expect ACORN to go down without a fight. Apparently though giving advice to help prostitutes ship in underage prostitutes is okay to most people, but personally I don't want my tax money paying for that type of "help." You can lie to yourself all you want, but ACORN exploits race and class for political gain. It uses divisive tactics to make neighbors hate neighbors destroying the communities they are attempting to "rebuild." Personally, thats not something that I feel the community chest should be opened for. Not only that but they lie to cover themselves up, for example stating that these activists where "thrown out" which video evidence has shown did not occur. Of course the right has groups that do the relatively the same stuff, which i feel should be defunded of public funds as well. But until those groups are exposed, ACORN is going to be the focus for most media. As always its not left vs. right, its tyranny vs freedom, any group that seeks to exploit others for personal benefit should not have access to tax money. That money is reserve for the state to protect my life, liberty, and property not make sure we fund criminal groups, whether these groups have democratic or republican support.
  • It's called "The Defund ACORN Act", it's unconstitutional to write legislation specifically targeting an individual or group.
  • TaterSalad
    Unlikely to win this case you say?? It can't even make it to the court system. You can't sue Congress! Period!
  • greenlightwilly
    "...ACORN exploits race and class for political gain. It uses divisive tactics to make neighbors hate neighbors destroying the communities they are attempting to "rebuild." ...Your opinion, to be taken seriously, must be supported with credible references. Otherwise, it's just a better-than-average constructed piece of fiction.
  • BillJ-MN
    Apparently though giving advice to help prostitutes ship in underage prostitutes is okay to most people, but personally I don't want my tax money paying for that type of "help."

    It wouldn't be ok, but we didn't see ACORN do any such things. Go back and watch those videos. Listen carefully to see if any ACORN worker makes any direct reference to prostitution rings or underage prostitutes. THEY DON'T. NOT ONCE. The only place you hear mention of those topics is from the off-screen voice of a heavily edited video.

    Is it really believable that in conversations with over a dozen ACORN workers, discussing those topics, that not a single one of them would utter some words making direct reference to the topics? I find it stretches my credulity too far to accept as fact. I believe it's more likely that the questions were inserted to match the answers in the editing room.

    We'll never know unless the unedited videos are made available for review. That'll never happen.
  • I don't want my tax money going for wars, especially ones we were lied into. ACORN, even though on that video, did some stupid things...you can't extrapolate that an entire group of half a million people are like that due to less than 10 on a video. That's fallacious thinking. KBR employees raped a woman and held her captive. Does that mean ALL KBR rapes women and holds them captive? KBR has electrocuted soldiers and did slave trafficking, too. Also, they gave our troops contaminated water and defrauded the government out of tens of millions of dollars, all on record.
  • The elephant in the room is this: Republicans and the right want to defund ACORN because they're "niggers".
  • Savantster
    .
    From what I read elsewhere, the bill targets ACORN, despite the broad language, it's named directly in the bill. That becomes the bill of attainder.

    for the rest, your logic is flawed. First, "ACORN" didn't encourage illegal behavior, some people working for ACORN did. Those PEOPLE should be removed, but the entire organization should not be held accountable and punished, especially without due process. Secondly, you know full well Congress has no intention of using the "broad language" of the bill against anyone else, they've already approved more spending on these other companies since this all went down. Third, maximizing the voice in a Democracy DOES protect your life, liberty, and property for without citizens voting, you have no valid Democracy. Spending a pittance of tax dollars to keep the Democratic Process viable is a reasonable expenditure of tax dollars. Shuttling the President back and forth as the most vacationing President in history, now THAT might be a waste of money. Perhaps it's time we set official vacation time for the President (and Congress) that is in line with what those making $75,000/yr get.. 3 or 4 wks, and that's it.

    ACORN is not a "criminal group", it's a group that had some people independently do something dumb. Leave the blame where it belongs, with those individuals.
    .
  • bowen
    I stand corrected, they have a case because you were right, they are mentioned specifically in the bill. But even if they win, i doubt the entire bill will be thrown out, and even if it does they can just draft a new one without that language. So in the end ACORN is still out of fed cash.

    Also though, How many more videos do you need to see before you see how this seems to be a system wide problem. Their top official was caught embezzling $5 million. There are some major ethics problem with the organization and they do not ferret out these people, and maybe in fact, encourage them to continue.

    And there is nothing democratic about ACORN, they pimp out housing loans as a way to buy support for candidates.

    Also maximizing voices in democracy that seek to tax me to pay for their programs in no way protects my property or liberty. I personally would not support ACORN in its current incarnation, yet i have no choice because our politicians choose to fund them. Not only that but they then grandstand on the "work" of ACORN as giving back to the community.

    Democracy is dangerous, as Ben Franklin said, "Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on whats for dinner, Liberty is a well armed sheep contesting the vote." Taxation is theft for supposed "beneficial" programs, Yet over and over again, as with the war, or bailouts, or katrina, gov't shows how inept it is, yet for some reason everyone thinks its this cure-all. Rely on yourself, and your family, and your community not gov't to solve your problems. Break out of the stockholm syndrome that the state has you in.
  • zentrails
    I meant ADD six zeros
  • zentrails
    Take all the taxpayer money that has gone to ACORN and multipy it by six zeros, what do you get????

    BLACKWATER!

    Why is Congress not de-funding Blackwater?
  • davidrvelasquez
    Lone ACORN workers only entertained the questions of two badly costumed middle class white kids posing as pros and pimp... Blackwater has undeniably committed murder, bribery and child prostitution.

    They should be fired by the US gov't.
    Gotta wonder what dirt they have on what politicians.
  • AdamTro
    Acorn should not be funded by taxpayers, period.
  • dennycrane
    The "banks" should not be funded by "tax payers." Hell, that's us! The "tax payers" money should be in "our" hands and put in the "hands" of institutions like "ACORN." The "right" people get to buy homes and the money goes back to the "tax payers." Hell, that's us.
  • Savantster
    .
    Nor should Blackwater, KBR, nor any other group that has been involved in crimes. Right?

    Right?

    *crickets*

    And why are you against spending tax payer dollars to help citizens better function in our Democracy? Why do you hate America so much that you want to have a broken Democracy?
    .
  • Richie73
    Acorn should be funded by taxpayers, period.
  • LiberalJesus
    Then neither should any other organization. Why are taxpayers footing the bill for big businesses failures but the congress decided to penalize a group that helps middle class and the poor without a voice? And what right did Congress have to be police, jury and judge in this matter? Where is the due process and the American way of innocent until proven guilty. ACORN didnt even get a trial and yet the crooks on Wall Street were already presumed innocent of squandering billions. It was all political grandstanding by ALL of the cowards, dems and reps in Congress. SHAME ON THEM ALL!
  • Richie73
    In the crazy parallel right wingoverse, it all makes perfect sense. Giving billions to criminal war contractors like Haliburton, Blackwater, etc. is ok, but a few million to help poor people- cue cries of outrage!

    Of course we all know what this is really about. One of the things Acorn does is register people to vote. And voter turnout is not the friend of the Republican party and its allies. Add to that the fact that the GOP has been doing what it accuses Acorn of doing - stealing elections (Florida 2000, Ohio 2004) - and it all makes sense why Acorn has to be demonized.

    Too bad corrupt, weak and cowardly democrats went along with it.
  • greenlightwilly
    Amen, Richie.
  • tomazulob
    Finally, an organization willing to show the cowards of the Congress for what they are: ill-informed, ignorant, and bending to the will of loud-mouthed liars.
blog comments powered by Disqus