Miss. school calls singing ‘gang activity,’ expels student

By Daniel Tencer
Wednesday, October 21st, 2009 -- 8:40 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

schoolbus Miss. school calls singing gang activity, expels studentSchool district accused of retaliation over earlier civil-rights suit

A mother in Mississippi has taken her local school district to court after her son was expelled from high school for what the school says was "gang activity" but what the mother and her supporters at the ACLU say was nothing more than singing and moving to the beat.

What's more, the lawsuit claims the school's actions were retaliation for an earlier civil rights lawsuit against the school board.

The 15-year-old student at Olive Branch High in Olive Branch, Mississippi, was expelled on the first day of the school year for what school officials say was "gang activity" -- the student, named only as "A.S." in the lawsuit, had allegedly made gang signs during a school assembly.

According to Courthouse News, when the student's behavior was noticed, "a police officer working at the school took A.S. to the principal's office, where he was accused of throwing 'gang signs,' then suspended and expelled."

Story continues below...

But the Mississippi chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, which is aiding A.S.'s mother in the suit, says the boy was merely singing to himself and "bopping his head and bumping his fists to the beat."

As the ACLU noted in a statement released earlier this week, A.S. was one of six students and their parents who filed a civil-rights suit against the DeSoto County School District alleging that "county authorities assaulted and racially discriminated against a group of schoolchildren riding home on a school bus."

The students won that lawsuit on August 6 of this year. On August 10, the first day of school, A.S. was expelled.

"To expel a high school freshman from school simply because he was singing to himself during an assembly is patently absurd," said Kristy Bennett, Legal Director for the ACLU of Mississippi, in a written statement. "A.S. has never been involved in gang activity and school officials never claimed that he was associated in any gang, disrupting any other students or interfering with any school activities. Rather, it is clear that A.S.'s expulsion was motivated by his involvement in the previous lawsuit."

Because the school district would not talk to the press, the local ABC affiliate had to get the school's side of the story from students.

“In our school handbook, you're not supposed to throw up gang signs," student Charles Jones told the TV station. “As to what I heard, he was like jumping around, throwing them [gang signs] up. He wasn't really cussing, but he was getting pretty close to it.”

The lawsuit marks the third time the ACLU has challenged the DeSoto County School Board in court. "Taken together, the lawsuits reveal a systemic pattern of arbitrary and unlawful conduct by school and police officials and highlight the disturbing national trend known as the school-to-prison-pipeline, wherein children are pushed out of public schools and into the juvenile and criminal justice systems," the ACLU stated. "All too often, as all three ACLU lawsuits show, children of color are disproportionately targeted by such policies."

A.S. has been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and the school "is aware of A.S.'s condition and has identified him as a student with special needs entitled to receive special education services," Courthouse News notes.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • m0rphine
    I hope they got sued there ass off. Some teachers who unnecessarily fuck with peoples lives by expelling people for no reason need there face blown off point blank with a double barreled shotgun and be cooked into biodiesel
  • texasaggie
    And the school administration knows that hitting yourself on the head is a gang sign. Right! Do they also know what gang this kid belongs to? Do they even know if he belongs to a gang? Are they a bunch of jerks? The evidence is incontrovertible that kevindo certainly is.
  • Oberon123
    Yeah, kevindo, you clearly are a racist. As is the bunch of thugs, er, school board members, of Mississippi. Idiot decisions like this are what you have when you give white trash positions of authority.
  • Fran Taylor
    kevindo is one of the knuckle-dragging neanderthals that still roam the earth. Thank goodness for the human beings at the ACLU.
  • skyballs
    So, if I'm reading your statement correctly, you saying that this kid should be locked up because you assume he will eventually kill someone because you suspect he is nothing less than a gang member? I think you should be locked up before you eventually lynch somebody, because I am assuming you are nothing less than a racist.
  • kevindo
    Everyone is a victim.... better to go ahead and send him to jail before he kills an innocent person. Go ahead, cry blood over my comment and call me a rascist.... the problem here is not the school, or the student... the problem here is Parenting (or rather lack of it). That child is out of control and his 'momma' is to blame... not society, not the school and not rap (though it should be outlawed for bad taste)... the ACLU could do a hell of a lot better than this.
  • Savantster
    .
    "out of control" because he's entertaining himself during a school assembly? Have you been to one of those? Sane and/or intelligent people go out of their minds dealing with that inane bullshit.

    And you have no idea what kind of parent she is, so how can you say there was a problem with her parenting? Because she isn't teaching her child to be seen, not heard? to be respectful of "authority" in all cases? to do what 'da massa say'?

    You're not a racist, you're a raging moron. Saying it's not "society" is you trying to say your ignorant views can't be wrong, but man o man.. not much right about anything you're projecting here in comments.

    Everyone is a victim, indeed. Why? Because we let those that came before us, with nothing but dumb luck, squat on all our resources and force everyone else to be beholden to them just so we can live..? In the old world it might have been reasonable to say "if you don't like it, just roam off that way and find your own resources", but that world is long gone. Everything has been claimed, and now everyone born is a slave to the old dynasties..?

    If we weren't being encouraged to stab each other in the back just to be able to live, we'd have a much better world. We're acting like hungry cavemen who need to beat anyone that comes near the scraps of food we've found.. but we've created an advanced society (technologically).. why can't we evolve the way we view our fellow man? .... why can't we "grow up" as a species and realize that we have plenty, we don't have to hoard (that's what greed is, really... deep rooted hoarding) to survive. We have EASY ways to get food, making safe shelter is a breeze.. Clothing is nothing more than an after thought these days. So why are we killing each other just to have more stuff that we don't need? Evolutionarily, we seem to be abused children given freedom for the first time, and we're going nuts grabbing all the candy off the shelves and gorging on it. .... and all the ills in our society are the upset stomach that comes with such excess.
    .
  • texasaggie
    Wouldn't it be nice if you knew what you were talking about before you said anything? Would that be asking too much?
  • woodsy
    Type your comment here. I am the mother of a ADHA child and you statement offends me. These children are ofter labeled trouble makers and it follows them all the way through school. Their mothers can't be with them 24/7 and we can't be blamed for everything they do. They usually have behavioral problems and learning problems. This is a problem for everybody. These children will someday grow and become dependent on tax payers for help with everyday needs. It would be in the best interest of everybody that programs be developed to help kids like this instead of punishing them because they have a disability. IT"S NOT ALWAYS THE MOTHER'S FAULT. WHAT ABOUT THE DAD.
  • damixaustex
    If they were planning on going after all seven kids who were involved in the earlier complaint, they've now got bigger troubles on their hands, especially if they left a paper trail. FOIA requests and discovery will show exactly how this district thinks.

    "These children will someday grow and become dependent on tax payers for help with everyday needs."

    True, but they are less dependent if the schools try to work something out before they send them out into the world.
  • damixaustex
    Maybe the first sentence should have read like this for ya.
    "A teenager who was involved in a federal complaint accusing a School District of racial discrimination has been expelled, on his first day as a freshmen in high school. The ACLU says it was an act of retaliation."

    Thing is, ACLU was already involved in the previous case, an incident on a special needs bus involving several middle school students, so they have to continue with this, naturally. Expelled on the first day of school? Will the others be expelled as well? All 7?

    Sounds to me like a collision of a tough gang policy meets Americans with Disabilities Act meets school administrators with dumb counsel.

    The question is, does the district have an obligation to figure out how to deal with troublesome special needs teens or do they owe it to other students to push A.S. away?

    Was it proper use of gang policy? Sure doesn't look like it. It sounds like it was the only thing they could dream up stronger than ADA.
  • texasaggie
    I don't think this has anything to do with gang policy. I sincerely doubt that these guys would know a gang if it beat them on the head. It strongly suggests, as you said, that the school administration was just looking for some excuse to get this kid and this is the best one they could come up with. It strikes me as the same thing as the "death panels" that the antihealth reform people came up with, pure wind but enough to scare ignorant people.
  • damixaustex
    Yeah, that's what I think too. I don't know about MS, but here in Texas, the public schools can't kick people out just because teaching them is a difficult. Under ADA, they also have to spend whatever money is necessary to accommodate a student with special needs.
    I liken it more to the Patriot Act being used to search peoples trunks for drugs. It's a misapplication of rules.
    I think they entered the school year with a plan to boot the ADHD student using the only tool they had to kick him out.
    Sad. Now the districts taxpayers are gonna get hit hard for bad decision making. They should be asking for the superintendents job. This district, 77% white, Memphis 61%, not a good scenario to act as they did.
  • lothar
    Jail is for those convicted of committing a crime. Getting expelled on questionable grounds isn't the same thing.
blog comments powered by Disqus