Feingold may not support watered-down health care reform

By David Edwards and Daniel Tencer
Wednesday, October 28th, 2009 -- 1:12 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

feingold3 Feingold may not support watered down health care reformKucinich: 'Will we stand for the people or the insurance companies?'

As evidence mounts that the public option faces an uphill battle in the Senate, its supporters are drawing a line in the sand and saying the Senate should not pass a watered-down health reform bill for the sake of drawing 60 votes.

"The mere fact that there's a bill on the floor is not enough for me to vote for it," Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI) told MSNBC's Willie Geist on Wednesday morning. "It certainly wouldn't match the historical moment to do something that's just health care reform in name only. We need to do something real. We need to do something to stop the insurance companies' dominance over the checkbooks and health care of Americans. And that means doing something significant."

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid announced on Monday that the health reform bill he will bring to the Senate floor will include a public option to compete with private health insurers. But no sooner had the Nevada Democrat made his announcement than reports began to spread that the public option doesn't have enough support in the Senate to overcome a Republican filibuster. All 60 members of the Democratic caucus would have to vote together to break a filibuster.

The likelihood of that happening was reduced on Tuesday when Sen. Joe Lieberman, an independent who caucuses with the Democrats, announced he would support an expected Republican filibuster of Reid's bill.

Story continues below...

On Wednesday, supporters of the public option raised the stakes, pressuring the Democratic congressional leadership to stand by plans for an alternative to private health insurers. House Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-OH) issued a challenge to Democrats to stand up to the health insurance companies working to block reform.

"This is a moment of truth for the Democratic Party," Kucinich said in a statement. "Will we stand for the people or the insurance companies?"

Said Kucinich: “We compromised on [a] single payer [health care system] by backing a public option, and now we are being asked to compromise the public option with negotiated rates. In conference, we will likely be asked to compromise negotiated rates with a trigger. In each and every step of the health care debate, the insurance companies have won. If they get hundreds of billions of dollars in new taxpayer subsidies, they get to raise their premiums, and increase their co-pays and deductibles, while the public is forced to pay for private insurance, then the insurance companies win big.

“If this is the best we can do, then it is time to ask ourselves whether the two-party system is truly capable of representing the American people or whether the system has been so compromised by special interests that we can’t even protect the health of our own people," Kucinich stated.

Progressive activists joined the chorus of political pressure as well. Jane Hamsher, founder of the FireDogLake blog, said Reid will "pay a price" with his home-state voters in Nevada if he allows Lieberman to side with the Republicans and block the health care bill.

"It's never happened before that one party had -- technically, in the caucus -- a filibuster-proof majority and one of the members went to join over with the opposition party," Hamsher told MSNBC's Rachel Maddow. "You have to ask yourself, 'What were they thinking when they let Joe into the caucus and didn't get him to agree to join with them on procedural votes?'"

But in his MSNBC interview on Wednesday, Feingold praised Reid for even managing to keep the public option alive in the Senate for as long as it has been.

"A lot of people thought we wouldn't even have a public option being discussed at this point," Feingold said. "It's only because of the courage of our majority leader, who I believe is doing this on principle."

This video is from MSNBC's Morning Joe, broadcast Oct. 28, 2009.



Download video via RawReplay.com

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • bayside
    How I wish Feingold was our president, he cares about .the people not corp...Check out the OECD website.....This is what our conservative centerist dems and republican have been doing for the last 30 years ..No wonder the world was relieved when they thought a progressive was in the white house..It is sad to know centerist conservatives are still in charge.. :

    In fact, the 40 other developed nations against which we measure ourselves . provide public funded universal health care,and they have a guaranteed living wage for its citizens



    We are the only country, in 40 industualized countries that doesnt include free universial health care coming out of taxpayers money. thanks to our conservative and centerist congressmen...I feel like I am the prey and they are the predators..
  • lorn
    Dennis will stand with the people, just as he always does.

    The Democrats will betray us, just as they always do.
    But they will put on a theatrical display of pretending they really tried hard to give us the health care that the rest of the civilized world takes for granted.

    The Republicans will betray us, just as they always do.
    But they will be blunt and direct in telling us that they favor big companies and don't really give a fcuk about regular people.

    Dennis and the Republicans are honest about their priorities. Democrats are liars.
  • lousgirl84
    There is nothing honest about republicans not even close. You are obviously one of them if you would call them honest and the Dems liars.
  • lorn
    The Republicans are fascists.......honest fascists. The Democrats are fascists too, but they have to be much better liars, and they are.

    Whenever they receive criticism from the left for their extremist right wing behavior, they always throw a fit and accuse the liberal of being a Republican, always. Like now.

    Both parties are corrupt criminal enterprises. They work together to deny us health care. Their devotees who worship and repeat every lie they spew are the reason they succeed.
  • "health care reform in name only" is Wealth Care for the Insurance Companies.

    Perhaps if our Democrats cannot deliver a good bill that provides either a Strong Public Option or Single Payer prior to Christmas, they should just vote against it and try again next year. A bad bill is worse than no bill.

    And push our Democrats to call for prosecution of those in the Bush-Cheney Torture Conspiracy (conspiracy to torture is a Federal Law with penalties of 20 years to life).

    SIGN the PETITION calling for Prosecution at http://ANGRYVOTERS.org


    .
  • farang
    Jane Hamsher always stands for the people, too bad we can't elect her and jettison Lieberman into deep space orbit....
  • damixaustex
    During this stage of every new law, Americans should have a right to review every single communication between everyone involved. It's not enough to have the evening programs reporting on what Congress is doing. The deliberation, the tit for tat they do to garner votes should be recorded, videoed, everything, including phone calls and private meetings, email, everything between Congressmen, their underlings and their spouses.

    Only then can we restore faith in the system.

    Maybe we should have a constitutional amendment calling for transparency in government.
  • overdoneputaforkinit
    We have a situation in this country which is similar to why the Founders sought independence from Britain. We have taxation without representation again today. Congress represents the interests of big industry over the interests of The People. The will of a handful of large insurance companies weighs more than hundreds of millions of taxpaying Americans!
  • WhiteHorseBlindersOff
    Well people have been mulling around other names like the "competitive" option or the "consumer" option, I'd think it be better called the "We can run deficits and set any price we wish so we can eventually price private insurance out of the market and get to single payer without even having to vote on it before medicare and social security go bankrupt that way we will have the people by the balls when we have to raise taxes above European levels because we have a large defense budget as well" option.

    This is being pushed by idiots and liars. They are admittedly not being straight with the American people. Bush lies cost this country hundreds of billions of dollars and thousands of lives (our soldiers). Obama's lies will cost us more of both. Bush wanted to tap your phone and computer without a warrant whenever they wanted and Obama agrees. What do you think they are going to do to your body? Soros himself has already said that China is the ideal.
  • nader paul kucinich gravel
    Single Payer will now be ON "the table" Pelosi
blog comments powered by Disqus