Democrats strip single-payer healthcare proposal from health overhaul

By John Byrne
Friday, October 30th, 2009 -- 8:56 am
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

sad kucinich Democrats strip single payer healthcare proposal from health overhaulA government-run healthcare program may become an "option" for those who don't have employer-sponsored healthcare coverage, but a government-run healthcare system will not.

House Democratic leaders quietly stripped a single-payer provision from the House version of the healthcare overhaul Thursday. The measure would have allowed states to set up their own state-run healthcare systems, where local governments would have become de facto health insurers for residents.

A Democratic aide told Roll Call that there was "consensus" to remove the provision, which was proposed by Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-OH) and inserted by a majority vote in the House Education and Labor Committee.

“The fact is, the majority of the Democratic Caucus agreed that the most effective way forward was through a competitive marketplace coupled with strong consumer protections and the choice of a public option,” Education and Labor Committee spokesman Aaron Albright remarked.

Kucinich's amendment had been added to the bill in a bipartisan 27-19 vote in the Education and Labor Committee. While supported by liberals, the measure would likely have been a "poison pill" for the overhaul bill, where Democrats have struggled to round up votes for a "robust" public option.

Story continues below...

Kucinich said he was disappointed by the House leaders' move.

“Today, advocates of true health care reform were disappointed to learn that the Kucinich amendment was removed from the latest version of the health care reform bill," Kucinich said in a statement. "At the end of the day, states may be given the option to opt out, but won’t be allowed to opt into a proven system that provides all of a state’s residents with better health care.

“Many states are demanding single payer," he added. "The Lewin Group’s financial analysis of the California single payer bill that passed the legislature twice found that 'the net cost of the program to state and local governments is a savings of about $900 million' in 2006 alone. There are also strong single payer movements in Pennsylvania , New York , Illinois , Colorado , and New Mexico."

Facing the intransigence of Republicans to support any version of Democratic healthcare reform, the party has had to cater to its conservative and moderate wings to round up the necessary support to get the bill passed. Concessions have generally involved the watering-down of attempts to create a government-run competitor to private insurance companies.

Kucinich said he could "only conclude" his amendment was taken out of the bill “because of pressure from the insurance companies,” though moderate Democrats' resistance to such a wide-ranging proposal seems equally plausible.

“If a state wants better health care than can be provided by the federal government in the health care bill we are seeing today, the federal government should not stand in their way," the congressman said. "The removal of the Kucinich amendment constitutes yet another capitulation to the health insurance and pharmaceutical industries who are already reaping billions of dollars from the bill."

Canada, Australia and the United Kingdom all have single payer government run healthcare plans. The United States' healthcare system -- where private insurance companies control the market -- is largely an anomaly among developed Western economies.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • David
    Next Time I Donate money to his Presidential run.

    This man is a man of the people.

    He is the only member of the house that brought up impeachment of the Bush War criminal.

    He has my vote.
  • nader paul kucinich gravel
    Start the storm Dennis as we are ready.
  • dennycrane
    Who's your daddy? The lobbyists that oils your palms. Assholes. The only answer to this is Medicare Part "E", for "Everyone."
  • miggy
    I guess that “Joker” Obama face plastered on many posts and T-shirts has hit a nerve with many of the Elites. Could have easily been a Bush T-shirt as well.
    The PsyOp isn’t working very well is it?
    This isn’t about Public Vs. Private option as much as it is the perception or lack there of people recognizing that we’ve been had by both Red and Blue.
    They’re not the answer. We the American people are. They’re the Elitist and the ones who for right now control our fates as well as their own. It’s not so much about wealth.
    It’s about power and control. PERIOD!


    Until we as a Republic and Great Nation have the mortal fortitude to look back and hold individuals responsible for violations against our US Constitution High Treason, Federal and International crimes Accountable, we will not be able to move forward.
    It’s been a disgrace. Plain and simple. We’re FASICST now. Run by Elites and Oligarchy’s.
  • WJM51
    It's time to vote out EVERY business ass kissing democrat along with every GD republican in office and replace them with people who give a damn about HUMANS instead of money.

    I don't give a damn what the business sell outs we call congresspeople "think" about what the way to go is. They are supposedly in office to represent US, and WE know that this "competition" BS is just that: BULLSHIT. They want to keep the $$ rolling in from their big insurance bribers, and they will sell us out in a heartbeat to get just that.

    Kucinich was my choice, and he would STILL be my choice. He is the ONLY one of those running from any major party who gives a damn about US. He proved that every time he turned around. The rest show their contempt for us every time.

    Time for PUBLIC financing of ALL elections. NO private money, or it's jail time. NO corporate money PERIOD, or it's the corporate death penalty. Until we get rid of this system of institutionalized bribery, nothing will EVER change.
  • donofcali
    More bullshit from the spineless dems. At this point, all Liberals in congress should vote AGAINST the bill.
  • musashi
    fucking whores to the insurance industry, thats
    the change we get from democrats huh?
    fucking chump change! im now officially an independant! obama is a fraud, democrats are the
    new republicans, republicans are the new nazis.
    the whole fucking system is broken. time to organize
    a tax strike, nobody pay the irs. fuck em! taxation without representation is what started this country,
    may as well be what puts it out of its fucking misery!
  • jimbo92107
    They're setting it up to fail. Do not forget this betrayal.
  • laydownthelaw
    its time to vote everyone out except for Al franken and a select few others. Obama has till the end of this term to get his butt in gear before he needs to pack his things too.
  • starvapor
    Screw voting in more replacement clones of what we already have.
    It's time to go directly to the heart of the problem....go after the insurance lobbyists with some extreme influence, find out where they live, dine, what driving routes they take, etc.,' ya know what I mean?
  • lucky
    Once again, this shows we won't have a true democracy until we have public elections for all federal offices, and prohibit private funds to be used by any elected officials.
  • Hologram5
    All politicians should be stripped of their cush public jobs. They'll start dying off soon and realize just how nasty our health care really is here.
  • Hologram5
    A Democratic aide told Roll Call that there was "consensus" to remove the provision
    ------------------------------
    This is because they don't want states to have any control over anything. They want total control.
  • davidrvelasquez
    FLUSH THIS BILL.!


    Fuck the dems and the GOP.

    ..maybe someday in the future we'll get a political party with actual guts in place of the Jell-O these spineless greedy wimps currently have.
    Then and only then will it be possible to having meaningful healthcare reform.

    But then, people get the gov't they deserve. If americans are suffering its because americans are allowing it.
  • wallacewpancoast
    Do it right or get it rejected as a sham! Those who don't want a strong health care public option really don't want a health bill at all. This should be the way in which we tell our "fair- weather friends" we want a real bill, and will accept nothing less. Strength begets strength: weakening
    Health Care is not a way to get a meaningful health care law. If Obama is willing to accept a
    "pretend" health care bill he is not really for change at all. Let's accept the reality: we are not
    the "heroes" we pretend to be. Let's hope our next generation has more guts than we.
  • miggy
    No Regulation of a God Given ( Insert Spiritual God) Inalienable Right is going to change the discourse. That is if you take the Bill of Rights and US. Constitution seriously. Which, of the last Nine years we haven’t.
    On a broader perspective, the political process is broken. Both Houses are brought and paid for with Corporate Money. It basically buys and makes our Laws nowadays. You don’t have to look any further than The Patriot Act, Military Comm. Act and John Warner Defense Act to realize that Perpetual War under a Unilateral Executive plus War Profiteering from our Tax Dollars with a out of control Fed. Reserve equals disaster.
    HealthCare, is The Globalists/Elites last bubble. The Pubic Option is their Defeat. And they know it.
  • tonybinca
    Hope and change = Hopeless chump change. Way to go Ozombies
  • socialismorbust
    KUCINICH IN 2012!!!

    Had "alleged progressives" followed their beliefs and values instead of fearing McCain and the terrorist party, Dennis J. would be in the white house. What a pathetic group of whores and criminals behind the "RAPE THE CITIZENS" bill that is bought, paid for, and written by BIG PHARMA!!!
  • davidrvelasquez
    I don't think it was the voters in 2008 so much as the dem leadership in cahoots with the M$M in freezing Dennis out. The selection process seemed heavily manipulated.
  • daman2012
    You guys elected a senator that voted "present" on most everything before him in congress...what did you expect?
blog comments powered by Disqus