Bush Administration covered up global warming finding, then deliberately kept from Democrats

By The Associated Press
Tuesday, October 13th, 2009 -- 9:30 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

bushpodiumseal20081010 Bush Administration covered up global warming finding, then deliberately kept from DemocratsAn e-mail message buried by the Bush administration because of its conclusions on global warming surfaced Tuesday, nearly two years after it was first sent to the White House and never opened.

The Bush administration, and then EPA administrator Stephen Johnson, refused to release the document when it was written in 2007, and labeled it "deliberative, do not distribute" to Democratic lawmakers. The White House instead allowed three senators to review it in July 2008, when excerpts were released.

The e-mail and the 28-page document attached to it, released Tuesday by the Environmental Protection Agency, show that back in December of 2007 the agency concluded that six gases linked to global warming pose dangers to public welfare, and wanted to take steps to regulate their release from automobiles and the burning of gasoline.

The document specifically cites global warming's effects on air quality, agriculture, forestry, water resources and coastal areas as endangering public welfare.

That finding was rejected by the Bush White House, which strongly opposed using the Clean Air Act to address climate change and stalled on producing a so-called "endangerment finding" that had been ordered by the Supreme Court in 2007.

Story continues below...

As a result, the Dec. 5 e-mail sent by the agency to Susan Dudley, who headed the regulatory division at the Office of Management and Budget was never opened, according to Jason Burnett, the former EPA official that wrote it.

The Obama administration in April made a similar determination, but also concluded that greenhouse gases endanger public health. The EPA is currently drafting the first greenhouse gas standards for automobiles, and recently signaled it would attempt to reduce climate-altering pollution from refineries, factories and other large industrial sources.

In response, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Republican lawmakers have criticized the EPA's reasoning and called for a more thorough vetting of the science. An internal review by a dozen federal agencies released in May also raised questions about the EPA's conclusion, saying the agency could have been more balanced and raising questions about the difficulty in linking global warming to health effects.

The agency released the e-mail and documents after receiving requests under the Freedom of Information Act.

Adora Andy, a spokeswoman for EPA administrator Lisa Jackson, said Tuesday that the draft shows the science in 2007 was as clear as it is today.

"The conclusions reached then by the EPA scientists should have been made public and should have been considered," she said.

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • CosimodiRondo
    Plausable deniability. "I didn't suppress global warming advice. I just never read it!" fingers in ears...LALALALALALALALALALALA
  • Thomas Jefferson
    see, in the neo-cons world if you don't open that email on global warming, global warming never existed.

    morons truly defines the term, "motherfucker". what a colossally stupid fuck.
  • bill clinton
    the bush administration proves once again they just lie....

    they lied about 9/11

    they lied about iraq

    now they lie about this...


    yet the biggest lie...their cover up of the banking industry for 3 years is what will bring down America...
  • Max_1
    Q U E S T I O N:
    Will we wait until the planet farts us into extinction to prosecute BushCo?

    Not only have they poisoned the Middle East with nuclear radiation through depleted uranium POISONING, they PURPOSEFULLY hid climate data about a climate change/disaster that can potentially can kill us all.
  • samhouston
    Bush/Cheney certainly had total control over then-EPA Administrator Stephen Johnson, who buried this report.

    Steve, you weren't "William Ruckelshaus" -- you were closer to being "Anne Gorsuch Burford". You had the chance to serve the people, but you wanted the "job" working for Bush/Cheney more. Wonder how you justified your treachery in light of the oath you took for the job at EPA?

    The world's best scientists have concluded that the world is on a collision course with climate change that make life unsustainable for a huge percentage of people on Earth. In simpler terms, that means protracted deaths as they attempt to cope. I can only conclude that you are a remorseless right wing-nut.
  • paddles57
    Bush lied-the world fried.
  • nellieh
    Was Inhofe one of the three Senators? If so, who are the other two? Are they all Republican and outspoken critics of global arming? It would be helpful to know their names.
  • imwc
    public welfare was never one of the monkey`s strong suits...just the opposite to be exact...
  • radii
    bush was installed to give the fossil fuel industry their last hurrah (and to be israel's lapdog)
  • damixaustex
    How's about a 50 year moratorium on oil Presidents. Sorry, Mrs. Palin.
  • EvanRavitz
    Hey, Bush League and Chamber of Horrors: burn in Hell!
  • christopherlaw
    Ah, Another War Crime, on our Global community!!!
  • Not to worry. Three Senators got the report; Thants, Karl. Anything that might be said about the report will be (please check one): Biplartisian, Against reform.
  • CosimodiRondo
    Plausable deniability. "I didn't suppress global warming advice. I just never read it!" fingers in ears...LALALALALALALALALALALA
  • Mr. Neutron
    In response, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Republican lawmakers have criticized the EPA's reasoning and called for a more thorough vetting of the science.
    -------------
    The Republicans will go the way of the Whig Party over this issue. Climate Change is going to make the GOP label toxic within a decade - watch for a new evil-rich party coming soon. The "Freedom" Party, or "Patriot" Party, or "America is Great" Party, something the mouthbreathers down South will be proud of. And they'll spin it as "the Republicans lost their way, they weren't true to the principles that made this country great blah blah blah".
    It will NOT be a bankruptcy for the GOP, shedding toxic assets and reorganizing under a new label with less association with incompetency and criminality, no siree.
    It will be NOTHING like Arthur Andersen screwing up big time on auditing Enron and being convicted, then spinning of Accenture, nothing like that AT ALL...

    Freedom Party - making America Great Again.
  • CharlieL
    Oh no, really? That's SOOOO hard to believe.
  • rexozone
    The bush administration wanted to water board all of us.
    And with polluted water at that.
    Can they be incarcerated now? Please?
  • tacticalgrace
    No shit you just finding this out RS ? This is sooooo old news.
  • caroldw
    Obama's EPA perfectly mirrors his wishy-washy, little of this and little of that policies.
    This report "should have been considered"? If you don't craft policy on the best science available you are cheating your constituents, (in the case of the president that's all of us) and pose a significant danger to the planet.
    Obama has managed to accomplish something that is nearly impossible: to craft policies that have no constituency and make everyone unhappy.
  • arnold benedict
    Global warming is so last year.... get the real data we are in a cooling trend now.
blog comments powered by Disqus