Hospital sends parents $29,000 bill after son is murdered

By Muriel Kane
Thursday, November 5th, 2009 -- 11:00 am
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

hawkinsparents110509 Hospital sends parents $29,000 bill after son is murderedShortly after the funeral of California student Scott Hawkins, who was beaten to death by his college roommate on October 23, his parents received a second shock.

A bill for $29,186.50 arrived from the hospital where Hawkins had been taken after being found unconscious in his dorm room, along with a form letter telling "the patient" that he was considered indigent and should seek further treatment through county health services.

Gerald and Elizabeth Hawkins had been informed by Sacramento State College that their son was already dead when his body was discovered and were not aware that he had received level 5 trauma care for five minutes in the hospital emergency room.

"It was just devastating and insulting," Gerald Hawkins stated. It's just hard to grasp for words. My wife and I were near collapse."

"It was just awful," Elizabeth Hawkins told CBS13 News. "I don't think there's any civilized country, anywhere in the world that would allow the parents of a murdered boy to receive a bill like this. ... When you have barely enough energy to finish your sentences, having to sit down and deal with something like this out of the blue is extremely difficult."

Story continues below...

UC Davis Medical Center issued a statement apologizing for the "clerical error" and explaining that "the patient's death in the emergency department should have been flagged as a death in the outpatient record." That would have generated a letter of sympathy and a tactful inquiry about the family's insurance.

Hawkins was a transfer student who had only been rooming for a short time with his alleged attacker, Quran Jones, and it was not clear what prompted the attack. Death was attributed by a representative of the college to "blunt force trauma," and one police spokesperson said Hawkins had been beaten with a baseball bat, although this has not been confirmed.

When police responded to reports of the disturbance, they found Hawkins unconscious and Jones wielding an eight-inch knife. Jones was shot by police as he advanced with the knife and will be charged with murder when he recovers.

Share this article:
  • Print this article!
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • farang
    [A bill for $29,186.50 arrived from the hospital where Hawkins had been taken... he had received level 5 trauma care for five minutes in the hospital emergency room.]

    Wow. A whole 5 minutes, eh?? Only $29,186.50? Golly, why so cheap???

    Meanwhile "pro-lifer" Bachmann teabaggers march on D.C. to demand government "not take away their healthcare...."

    It's like hallucinating, and no drugs involved. WEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!
  • tony
    Why is this so hard to grasp? Twenty minutes in my Pain Specialists' office costs me $1200.00 because I am considered "un-insurable' in America!
  • sambarber
    See? Who are these liberal asses who say we need Health Care Reform? The system works perfectly!



    NOT
  • truthops2010
    We always hear about "irresponsible" people getting free treatment at emergency rooms. What is never pointed out, is that the hospital bills EVERYONE, and NO ONE is forgiven of the expense, save the instances appeals have worked to get the charges lowered. The fact that this hospital got their records screwed up and sent this bill to his parents is indeed appalling, but what is just as appalling, is that anyone in this country can get a bill for 30,000 f'ing dollars who just needed their life saved.
  • No, it ain't free. You do get it, but then the fun begins.

    Excellent point.
  • bobdevo
    I belieVe I can help the parents compose a two-word response to the hospital:

    GET FUCKED.
  • cc the collection agency while you're at it, and see how far you get
  • bobdevo
    Collection agency? The parents didn't authorize the treatment, and neither did the kid . . . he was dead.
  • Freedom's Toast
    Hey....I could use your help with some letters I need to write. I liike the way you write.

    On second thought, can I just plagiarize?
  • texasaggie
    A more subtle way of getting the same message across is to go to Mapquest and print out the directions from the hospital to Hell, MI.
  • Turnip
    I highly doubt that they did any "level 5" treatment deserving of $29K. They just inputted the codes, and out kicks a bill that includes anything and everything that could or should have been done to avoid lawsuit. If they charge you for it, they really can't get sued for not doing it, can they?

    "But, it's right there in the bill. .. .see, $29,000 to go through the motions and pronounce him dead".
  • tony
    why is it that we see everyone else as a criminal, crook, or a thief, but we are always right, we never screw up anything,and deserve a raise just for showing up to work on time everyday and doing what we are told to do by our Boss? it was a mistake, not a crime. I assume you have never made a mistake, or are you GOD?
  • VFRmark
    $29,000 for 5 minutes work is just SO WRONG, I bet Florence Nightingale is spinning in her grave.
    There are some things in life that just shouldn't be capitalized and exploited, this includes death, the traumatized parents have yet to recieve the funeral costs.
    Free market capitalism don't cha just love it?...
  • After my daughter died during labor due to medical negligence, UCLA hospital sent me a bill for 2 days of 'nursery care'. Maybe it's just the UC hospitals but I sincerely doubt it.
  • dennycrane
    Cruel.
  • lousgirl84
    Clerical error my ass They send the bills and want you to pay. They are scum sucking slime
  • surgethis
    29K for 5 minutes ... 14K was profit market markup ... hospitals are for profit so the least amount of care for the maximum amount of profit. Before I would pay this bill I would demand to see it itemized .. then I would want to see all the medical records and the attending hospital personals records as well. Never pay a hospital bill without seeing every detail ... and every line item.
  • tony
    yes it is a terrible and traumatic event for them to get such a letter. Yet everyday, in every town, city, and household, humans make mistakes. None of us are Gods, and yet we each expect everyone else to be when it is our turn at the wheel of life.
    we received a bill for $48,000.00 when my father died, from the Sisters of Charity Providence Hospital. The sad thing was he died 10 minutes before he got there, and never recovered. We even had to pay the bill. They did the best they could, and we praise them for it.
    Sorry if the world isn't perfect when you most need it to be, but it isn't news. It is an everyday occurrence, and until we each reach Sainthood, we will make mistakes everyday.
  • dennycrane
    It still goes against the story of the Good Samaritan and how christers are suppose to act. Otherwise the story has no meaning. Which justifies the plan of the republicans--- "don't get sick, if you do, die quickly." This works right into the religious with an added part "D" (for die)....."when you do get sick, oft yourself quickly so you can see "god."
  • tony
    If only christers acted like the "christians" they claim to be. never going to happen  in the years I have left.

    Free Tibet
blog comments powered by Disqus