GOP senator dodges tearful rape victim’s questions

By David Edwards and Daniel Tencer
Monday, November 2nd, 2009 -- 11:20 am
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

davidvitterethicscomplaint GOP senator dodges tearful rape victims questionsConfronted by an impassioned rape survivor at a town hall Saturday night, Sen. David Vitter tried everything from sympathizing to deflecting blame onto the Obama administration for his decision to vote against an anti-rape amendment.

Finally, amid shouts from protesters, the Louisiana Republican simply walked away.

Vitter was one of 30 Republican senators who voted against Sen. Al Franken's amendment, passed in the Senate last month, that would de-fund government contractors who prevent employees from seeking justice when they have been raped.

The inspiration for the amendment was Jamie Leigh Jones, who was allegedly gang-raped by co-workers at Halliburton subsidiary KBR while on assignment in Baghdad, and was then prevented from pursuing the matter in courts.

At the town hall meeting Saturday, a woman identifying herself as a "rape survivor" confronted Vitter and asked him why he voted against the amendment.

Story continues below...

"I'm a rape survivor, and it meant everything to me to put [away] the person who attacked me," she told Vitter.

Vitter responded, "I'm absolutely supportive of any case like that, that they are prosecuted criminally to the full extent of the law."

"But there are rape victims that are being silenced," the unnamed woman responded. "How can you support a company that tells a rape victim that she does not have a right to defend herself?"

"Do you realize President Obama was against that amendment, and his administration was against that amendment?" Vitter asked.

"But I'm not asking Obama, I'm asking you, senator," the woman said.

At that point, Vitter walked briskly away from the woman and out of the town hall.

"What if it was your daughter that was raped, would you tell her to be quiet?" the woman shouted as Vitter walked away. "Would you tell your daughter to be silent?"

Vitter's assertion that the Obama administration opposed the amendment is only partly correct. The Pentagon opposed the amendment because it argued it would be virtually impossible to enforce. The White House stated that it supported "the intent of the amendment," but wanted to see it re-worked "to make sure it is enforceable."

This video is from YouTube, broadcast Oct. 31, 2009.



Download video via RawReplay.com

Share this article:
  • Print this article!
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...
  • davewtf
    The Rethuglican's only have empathy for zygotes and gun-nuts and white Americans who vote republican - and then only if the white Americans have lots of money...
  • why1
    In this case are Republicans on the wrong side of justice?

    http://www.youpolls.com/details.asp?pid=6417
  • jimbo92107
    Why are Republicans pro-rape? They voted for rape, so they really should explain.
  • missskeptic
    So much for accepting responsibility for one's actions.
  • hoosierdaddy
    "Do you realize President Obama was against that amendment, and his administration was against that amendment?"
    This motherfucker flat out lied to one of his constituents, to her face!!!!
    In any other country, guy's political carreer would be toast. But not in America where the corporations are the only entity our politicians are concerned with.
    Money talks, bullshit walks.
  • lousgirl84
    I FEEL YOUR PAIN!!!
  • socialismorbust
    Fucking coward! Vote him out!!! He's SCUM!!!
  • JulezSD
    What a A**hole!
  • Name
    If it doesn't involve diapers on a grown man, then its not important enough to take Senator Vitter's time.
  • overdoneputaforkinit
    He had no argument for voting against it. He talked over her disrespecting her and tried to change the subject person. Then the cowardly low life politician runs away with his lizard tail between his legs.
  • damixaustex
    "What if it was your daughter that was raped, would you tell her to be quiet?"

    Yeah, and what if it was your son????
  • zogtheobvious
    What do you mean?
  • damixaustex
    Is Vitters flippant attitude towards these rape victims due to the fact that they are girls?
    What if they were boys? Would his attitude be different?
  • Mooftown
    Oooof, what a dirty bastard, he doesn't give a shit about that lady... and why deflect towards talking about obama, this woman isn't trying to play games here, she wants a straight answer, what a cold-hearted soul-less sellout :I(
  • donofcali
    "What if it was your daughter that was raped, would you tell her to be quiet?" the woman shouted as Vitter walked away. "Would you tell your daughter to be silent?"

    Republicons don't have any empathy. That is one of their most significant and vile characteristics. Vitter can't visualize his daughter in that situation; it's just not the way he rolls.
  • jimbobuddy
    What a chicken-shit coward.
  • lousgirl84
    WHY IS THIS MF'ER NOT IN JAIL.
  • dennycrane
    Of the thirty "rape-publikans" that voted against it ,not one woman joined them. Why there are women and blacks in that shitty party is beyond me. It's like watching an episode of "Mad Men."
  • jdouglas
    "These are the times that try men's soles."
  • RevolutionDynamo
    You mean, becasue the Republicans 'run away' from the tough questions?
blog comments powered by Disqus