ACLU: Obama’s reversal on Patriot Act reform ‘a major travesty’

By Sahil Kapur
Monday, November 30th, 2009 -- 1:33 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

patriotactprotest ACLU: Obamas reversal on Patriot Act reform a major travesty

Key components in the USA Patriot Act are set to expire at the end of the year, but President Barack Obama is seeking to extend them, reversing his stark opposition in the past to the same provisions.

"The president's reversal on Patriot Act reform is a major travesty," said Michelle Richardson, Legislative Counsel for the leading civil rights group ACLU, in an interview with Raw Story. "There have been many, many abuses of power in the last four years."

These three main aspects in question allow the government to acquire private information about civilians through warrantless wiretapping of phone calls and emails, as well as seizure of records from credit reporting companies, banks, internet service providers and libraries. Another component includes the loosening of conditions under which an individual can be accused of providing "material support" to terrorists.

In 2005, then-Senator Obama pledged to filibuster a Bush-sponsored bill that included several of these exact components, calling it "just plain wrong" in a Senate speech.

Story continues below...

"Government has decided to go on a fishing expedition through every personal record or private document -- through library books they've read and phone calls they've made," he declared, adding: "We don't have to settle for a Patriot Act that sacrifices our liberties or our safety -- we can have one that secures both."

ABC News reports that "Four years ago, then Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., who taught constitutional law, voted down the same provisions along with all Senate Democrats who insisted on changes to the bill that better protected libraries, limited clandestine search warrants, roving wiretaps, and FBI gag orders."

"This was the most opportune time for the surveillance authorities to reverse course," Richardson told Raw Story. "If these programs continue, more abuses of power are absolutely inevitable -- there's no way around it. The level of secrecy granted by Congress is very troubling."

Obama has championed the continuation of all three provisions until at least 2013, a wish that has been granted by the Senate Judiciary Committee and two-thirds fulfilled by the House counterpart. (The House version slaps greater oversight and restrictions on acquiring personal records of non-US citizens.) While he has always been resolutely opposed to former President George W. Bush's vision of the Act, he has defended certain parts of it, and voted in 2006 to re-authorize an altered version.

"Overall, the Obama administration has made marginal improvements but is largely a continuation of the Bush administration with respect to civil liberties," Richardson told Raw Story, referring to the president's rising acquiescence to his predecessor's approach.

The Patriot Act, initially pushed through Congress quickly after 9/11 by the Bush administration as an alleged necessity to combat future attacks, has long been fiercely criticized by the ACLU and other civil libertarians as a gross violation of privacy rights under the Constitution.

Salon's Glenn Greenwald, a former civil rights litigator, recently wrote: "Democrats spent so many years screaming bloody murder over Bush's use of indefinite detention, military commissions, state secrets, renditions, and extreme secrecy -- policies Obama has largely and/or completely adopted as his own."

Share this article:
  • Print
  • email
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...

  • Annnnnnn
    The spin-off of fear and the aggressive Patriot Act are organizations such as Infoguard and other police citizen groups. It is addictive to those that participate by the hundreds and yet it is not clear what they believe they are doing to protect freedom or to defeat terrorism. Lies, gossip, false accusations, the ignorance of the Constitution and the purpose of the 4th Amendment, the psychological consequences of mass stalking on neighbors, the rudness, hateful yells, all this activity is strange and can be terrifying to anyone caught in the web. Somehow the money given to States for police and programs that were not to be constructed to cause this harm, are now back and causing harm. Businesses participate. If you are somehow a target because you do not like your picture taken by a person in a vehicle and you ask the police to suspend this activity -- explain it or end it -- if you know of no crime that you have committed or any crime someone you know has committed, you believe you have the right to ask about this odd mobbing in cars. If your name is then given by the police to a group in your town you are marked and now your life, your home, and your everyday business is their business. What the hell is going on!!! Are we in America or are we in pre-war Germany? Is this the doing of my candidate Biden who seemed to have been obsessed with money to COPS or is this the doing of some local organization -- a state organization? It would seem that there is a good reason to be vigilant and to be alert but I don't see how this is related at all and is very destructive to the person that is the target.
  • babs
    The last thing I expected but the final blow to any idea I had about change. Obama has not been the leader that I had hoped for and certainly there is no excuse for a constitutional law professor to support this lack of legal protection for citizens. He also seems to be totally unaware of the consequences to civil rights and the message this gives local law enforcement in places where fear congregates and vestors.
  • madprogressive
    Here we go again. Is there anything Obama promised to reform during the campaign he actually plans to reform. For those of you out there still defending Obama with this nonsense about some Ali rope-a-dope, and all that junk; when will you finally wake the hell up. I warned my family and friends of his potential do exactly what he is doing. I voted for Obama with the "Hope" he would actually believe in and fight for what he campaigned on, but I understood he is a "Politician", nothing more, nothing less. And that is why I'm not surprised at his constant reversals and failures, am I disaapointed, YES, but surprised, no. Change we can believe in my ass!
  • yvonneo
    Instead of simply not voting, I say we vote every encumbent (with few exceptions) out of office while they still allow us to vote. The democants and repukes are two sides of the same coin and each side has made it perfectly clear that they do not work for or in the best interests of the American people; they only work to further the interests of their evil bankster/corporate masters.

    So instead of just rolling over and letting these corrupt politicians walk all over us, the American people need to grow a spine and stand up en masse to these bastards and fight them and their bankster/corporate masters tooth and nail every step of the way. Give them no peace. If we must go down, let us at least go down fighting.

    Why do we continue to listen to, cooperate or follow these assholes when they lie to and deceive us at every opportunity? They have not been good stewards of America. We have been robbed blind and will be left completely destitute if we continue to allow them to do this to us. I'm sick and tired of their worn out dog and pony shows designed only to deceive and trick the people into thinking they're working so hard for us, when in fact they are working against us at every turn.

    Our so-called "leadership" has made it perfectly clear in every conceivable way that they are out to completely destroy our Constitution and the American way of life. And they have clearly demonstrated that they have absolutely no respect for the people, the Constitution, the rule of law, or any of the principles upon which our country was founded. What pukes they are.

    The enemies of America are not thousands of miles away on the other side of the planet; they're much closer--they're in DC working together to destroy our rights and freedoms and thus destroy everything America has ever stood for.
  • truthy
    Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
  • Satan
    Can't wait till the fucker is burning in hell with all of the other oligarchs.
  • Satan
    Can't wait till the fucker is burning in hell with all of the other oligarchs.
  • Mandyzzz
    Awwwwwkward!
  • westietra1
    Obama need a new Chief of Staff it seems all we get from Rahm is more Bush policies than what we voted for .
  • jimhadstate
    And then they wonder why nearly 1/2 of the Democratic base is not likely to vote next year. Would you if all it got you was another kick in the teeth or a polite STFU from Rahm?
blog comments powered by Disqus