Study: Bush administration blocked efforts to prevent housing crisis

By Daniel Tencer
Tuesday, October 6th, 2009 -- 10:42 am
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

house for sale Study: Bush administration blocked efforts to prevent housing crisisFederal regulators in the Bush administration blocked attempts by state governments to prevent predatory lending practices that resulted in the financial crisis now stalking the American economy, a new study from the University of North Carolina says.

In 2004, the Office of the Currency Comptroller, an obscure regulatory agency tasked with ensuring the fiscal soundness of America's banks, invoked an 1863 law to give itself the power to override state laws against predatory lending. The OCC told states they could not enforce predatory-lending laws, and all banks would be subject only to less-strict federal laws.

Now, a research paper (PDF) from UNC-Chapel Hill's Center for Community Capital shows that those anti-predatory lending laws had actually worked. States that had stricter regulations on issuing mortgages were found to have fewer foreclosures.

"We believe that these findings are remarkable, since they suggest an important and yet unexplored link between [anti-predatory lending laws] and foreclosures," the study's authors state.

The study may be the first scientific evidence to back up claims made by many critics that the Bush administration and earlier administrations allowed last year's financial crisis to happen by not enforcing common-sense regulations on lenders.

Story continues below...

Last year, seven months before the collapse of Lehman Brothers and the ensuing government banking bailout, then-New York Governor Eliot Spitzer wrote a Washington Post column in which he described how the Bush administration blocked states' efforts to prevent a crisis in the mortgage industry.

Spitzer wrote:

Predatory lending was widely understood to present a looming national crisis. This threat was so clear that as New York attorney general, I joined with colleagues in the other 49 states in attempting to fill the void left by the federal government. Individually, and together, state attorneys general of both parties brought litigation or entered into settlements with many subprime lenders that were engaged in predatory lending practices. Several state legislatures, including New York's, enacted laws aimed at curbing such practices.

What did the Bush administration do in response? Did it reverse course and decide to take action to halt this burgeoning scourge? As Americans are now painfully aware, with hundreds of thousands of homeowners facing foreclosure and our markets reeling, the answer is a resounding no.

Not only did the Bush administration do nothing to protect consumers, it embarked on an aggressive and unprecedented campaign to prevent states from protecting their residents from the very problems to which the federal government was turning a blind eye.

Spitzer's Post column ran a month before the New York Times reported that federal authorities were investigating Spitzer as a patron of high-end hookers, ending his political career and long-running crusade against corporate malfeasance. Some observers, including investigative reporter Greg Palast, say this was not a coincidence.

The UNC study "is a perfect reminder, as Congress and the administration tackle financial regulatory reform, that not all regulations are onerous, anti-business, and aimed at choking off financial innovation," writes Mary Kane at the Washington Independent. "And it’s more evidence that borrowers buying beyond their means weren’t the only only players in the sub-prime mess."

Share this article:
  • Print this article!
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...
  • luschnig
    Who ever doubted that this Mega Recession was engineered by the Republicans in order to steal more money from Americans? Republicans and all other conservatives are predators, pure and simple.
  • BertHarvey
    oh, proof....whoopy.

    Wake me up when we have politicians with the testicular fortitude to DO SOMETHING with all this evidence.
  • scaredtoleavename
    Yes, And I am mortgage broker who tried to blow the whistle on a bank. I learned that I had to report an outrageous business practice that probably is illegal to the OCC. At the OCC I was put in touch with the complaint desk lady who made me feel like I was the wrongdoer! I started to take offense to her questions and tone, and then I could hear her typing up everything I said. It was very intimidating.

    The upshot was OCC did nothing and I got blackballed by the bank, which btw is what banks do to uppity mortgage brokers who try to defend their clients from wrongful fees.
  • rexozone
    Yup. They beat us badly, scared us almost to our deaths, well, scared some of us to our deaths, and lots of Iraqi's to their deaths; then walked the hell out the door with all the money. Ain't that nothin'?

    The republicans have so much to pay for and we are waiting.
  • Allen
    "attempts by state governments to prevent predatory lending practices that resulted in the financial crisis"

    States did and so did ACORN. None of the people who accepted ACORN counseling were people who got into loan default situations.

    The radicals who want to blame ACORN for everything should actually kiss ACORN for doing what they could. The housing defaults would have been far worse without the work ACORN did.
  • conebeatsyanks
    Did he do anything moral or memorable while he was in office?
  • theoracle
    How much more evidence do we need to realize that the eight years of the Bush/Cheney administration were by far the most corrupt and criminal eight years in American history, and it was all done intentionally to benefit only corporations, the Republican Party and conservatives in general...and to hell with our country and the rest of our nation's citizens?

    For instance, the Bush/Cheney administration in 2001 pulled a stunt similar to the one involving housing when they blew off an urgent request from California's governor to have the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission check into what was happening to the West Coast energy market. Months passed. Nothing was done. In the meantime, Enron gamed the West Coast energy markets, causing rolling blackouts, inflated energy prices, doubled and even tripled monthly utility bills for West Coast utility ratepayers. After getting caught, Enron went bust, Enron employees were thrown out on the street, Enron stockholders were screwed.

    What the Bush/Cheney administration DIDN'T do to avert the Enron meltdown set the pattern for the next eight years. Bush/Cheney officials DIDN'T heed all the terrorist warnings signs in mid-2001...and 9/11 happened, killing 3,000 U.S. citizens. Bush/Cheney officials DIDN"T listen to any of the skeptics, U.S. intelligence analysts or the U.S. War College who were against starting the Iraq War, but DID listen to Iraqi exiles like Ahmed Chalabi who'd spent years in exile in Iran...leading to tens of thousands of U.S. soldiers either dead or injured and hundreds of thousands of Iraqis (maybe over a million) either dead or maimed for life, with over four million Iraqis fleeing from their homes.

    Top Bush/Cheney officials also 1) outed the identity of a covert CIA agent, Valerie Plame Wilson, 2) withheld federal emergency disaster aid during Hurricane Katrina so the Republican Party's coordinated smear campaign against Louisiana Democrats would be more effective and 3) politicized every department in our nation's federal executive branch, violating the Hatch Act numerous times.

    Several years ago, someone coined a catchphrase that perfectly describes today's Republican Party (and especially the Bush/Cheney administration): Culture of Corruption.

    This still describes the Republican Party perfectly...the culture of corruption party that sneers at the U.S. Constitution, the rule of law, regulations or anything that stands in the way of their totalitarian takeover of our country. Common sense? Decency? Compassion and caring for their fellow citizens? The culture of corruption and rapacious greed Republican Party threw these out a long time ago.
  • gotkids
    This reinforces my theory that Pres George W. Bush and Fed Reserve Chairman Allen Greenspan were colluding to stem the flow of US dollars out of the treasury by allowing mortgage lenders to bundle sub-prime mortgages and sell them overseas. Commonly referred to as the global flow of funds, no state could or would be allowed to upset the applecart.

    Countrywide Financial, the largest purveyor of sub-prime mortgages which was later acquired by Bank of America flush with cash form Halliburton, Ker Mcgee, KBR and a host of war profiteers; served to launder the war money and nobody would be the wiser. The BofA connection I witnessed with my own eyes.

    If my history is correct and I have yet to verify this, this is not new. Mass foreclosures occurred shortly after the Vietnam War. So maybe, just maybe this is a sytem: War for Profit; Flush the Money through the Economy; and hope like hell that the rest of US don't choke on it. Where's Joseph Stiglitz when you need him?

    "Just because you don't believe thieves conspire, doesn't mean they don't or they won't to get higher." Raygon Gaddy, CLEAN AIR
  • joze46
    From the get go, when it comes to politics my personal believe is to reflect on accountability and address it. Now with that said, as many do, and learning through the Internet in Blogs like this my vision and opinion has developed a horrible conclusion about the current state of affairs.

    It is hugely obvious the Media such hate trash radio, and cable television news channels such as MSNBC, CNN, and FOX News have been and currently manipulating, oppressing, and selectively covering up the horrendous problem in the Bush administration. Bush and company is the most tradgic governing administration in the recorded history of politics, specifically American politics.

    All this time spent in secrets in a war for eight years, lives spent, others tortured, trillions in secret money deals, Americans, now draw the conclusion these Afghanistan and Iraqi are so corruptible they likely may not be able to be transformed to a democratic society. Worse, Iran, Pakistan either is now identified as the most important problem because of nuclear weapons.

    So one year into this mess the Republicans blame it as Obama’s war which is preposterous. The only moment with any honesty was when Chris Mathews finely admitted in careful discussion a make no mistake about phrasing, Bush handed Obama two wars and an economic “Depression” yes he finally used the word depression.

    From my view, MSNBC has been in cultural conflict with the general public discourse because of a huge, huge resource through knowledge and complicity with the former Federal Reserve board chairman. Having to know deals made and privy to very powerful banking and stock market concerns. When I found out Andrea Mitchell, now anchor and commentator on MSNBC is Allen Greenspans wife likely privy to years and years of trillion dollar deals done secretly through the Federal Reserve and most likely shared with MSNBC a America has right before our eyes the most hypocritical piece of corporate corruption ever contrived. They the media brought America to where we are now…Thank heavens for the Internet…
  • tomdennen
    Read, re-read and then read again Spitzer's comment - the Bush administration politically assassinated that man for speaking up.
  • gotkids
    That's no BS. Banks have a "Blacklist" which is a list of firms who have in the past or are currently representing clients suing any bank. If your firm is that list, no bank will hire your firm. How about some tort reform for the banks?
  • rxgary
    its time to charge these weasels with treason and after a fair trial ,and quick convictions, public executions. then we wont have to worry about other leaders trying that shit anytime soon.
  • marthamitchell2
    Has anybody ever discovered who Bush was really working for?
  • OldAtlantic
    Stupidity as the spirit of the age. Stupidity is the malice of the Bushes.
  • marthamitchell2
    The Bush dynasty is too rich and powerful to be stupid. What's curious is how they might further prosper by destroying their entire country and people, and how they can conscientiously live with what they've done.
  • yvonne
    The bush crime family is anything but stupid--and that includes georgie jr. They've had well over a century to fine tune their criminal expertise, and it works to their advantage when people under-estimate them. Also, I think it's curious that bush sr was knighted by the Queen of England--so I guess now he's sir george hw bush.
  • marthamitchell2
    They took all they could take from the American People, and gave little back. Their wars ran us broke while crime and corruption flourished in our country. Bush family has been active in American Politics, even the CIA, since well before 1980. They controlled the Presidency for 16 years; while Southerners and Californians held office since 1976. Corporate fascism and illegal drugs/crime prevail. And the wealth is in the hands of 1% of the population.

    It would be nice to know the Bush Family's master plan, particularly since they plan to continue in politics while crime/drug importation are notoriously rampant and prevalent in Texas and Florida.
  • texico
    And this dumbass was permitted to go on. Damn, where is the justice. Oh.........thats right they just kill whomever brings it up.......I can't wait to see justice served by the One and Only .Jesus Christ. The bushes and the clintons and all other criminals that are called the exectutive branch, congress and the senators....especially the cfr senators I hope to watch if possible
  • Savantster
    .
    Many "hope", like you do, that some fictitious being will dole out "Justice" in some "after life". That "belief" is what keeps millions upon millions from _insisting_ that Justice be served here on earth. Those same people that need living, breathing beings to mete out that Justice also "happen to believe in the fairy tale after life", at least in public. In private, they clearly don't adhere to their publicly stated "faith".

    We have one life. We have to punish those that abuse others because that's the only "fact" we can see. Pushing off that responsibility to fairy tales is exactly how the ruling elite continues to manage to abuse the public with impunity.

    Your god isn't going to save you. You must save yourself.
    .
  • eaglebrave1958
    Some one forgot to mention to you that there is no Jesus Christ in the manner of which you speak who will hold the Bushes or anyone else for that matter to judgement...may the good spirits however merge together to smother out the eveil beset up on us..enjoy and prosper...
blog comments powered by Disqus