Watchdogs: Health industry giving more to Congress than thought

By Daniel Tencer
Thursday, October 1st, 2009 -- 4:04 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

baucuswheelofcontributions Watchdogs: Health industry giving more to Congress than thoughtA joint study by two political watchdog groups has found that Sen. Max Baucus -- the Montana Democrat who authored the principal health care reform bill being debated in the Senate -- was a major recipient of "contribution clusters" from lobbyists linked to health care groups.

The study, from the Center for Responsive Politics and the Sunlight Foundation, says members of Congress working on health care reform are receiving more money from the health industry than people realize.

This is because private lobbyists are donating to politicians who have already received donations from the groups those lobbyists represent, a practice the watchdogs describe as "contribution clusters."

The "never-before-seen" numbers, as the Sunlight Foundation describes them, show that Baucus collected contributions from 37 outside lobbyists representing PhRMA, the pharmaceutical industry’s chief trade association, and 36 lobbyists who listed biotech firm Amgen as their client.

In all, 11 major health and insurance firms had their contributions to Baucus boosted through extra donations from 10 or more of their outside lobbyists.

Story continues below...

On Tuesday night, the Senate Finance Committee, which Baucus heads, voted down two proposals for a government-run public option for health care.

Baucus is third on the list for "contribution clusters" from the health industry, behind Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY), in second place, and Arizona Sen. John McCain, who came in first -- though, as the study noted, McCain's donations were likely inflated by his presidential campaign last year.

View the full donations list here.

The watchdog groups have created a graphic called "Max Baucus' Wheel of Health Care Contributions," which shows the senator's largest health care donor is California-based biotech firm Amgen. That company gave Baucus $111,000 in the two-and-a-half-year period, by way of direct donations and no less than 36 other lobbyists.

In second place is PhRMA, the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, an industry group that represents drug makers. They gave Baucus nearly $89,000 by way of 37 lobbyists. Among PhRMA's members are pharma giants AstraZeneca, Merck and Pfizer, all of whom also donated directly and by way of "contribution clusters" to Baucus.

"There is no indication that the extra giving by lobbyists was part of a planned effort by the health care firms to solidify their support among key members of Congress," the Sunlight Foundation notes in an article published Thursday. "But whether coordinated or not, the newly-found clusters of lobbyist giving clearly illustrate the intensity of the full-court press that the industry is currently waging on Capitol Hill."

-- Diane Sweet contributed to this report

Share this article:
  • Print this article!
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...
  • RCW
    Impeach or remove them from the committees!
  • Bia Winter
    This entire debate about Health Care Reform has made it painfully obvious how corrupt MOST of our Congressionals are; one only has to look at the bribes they accept from the Insurance and Big Pharma lobbies, starting with Baucus and Snowe, on down the line of influence.
    It's time to hand this decision to the PEOPLE!


    We should all be clamoring for a NATIONAL REFERENDUM on the health care issue, with a choice for Single-payer clearly on the poll. The PEOPLE should be deciding this, not a compromised and bribed Congress!
    There should be no reason this can't be organized in time for this November's voting season.

    The choices might be;


    1. Do Nothing and let the Insurance companies continue to have their way with US.
    In fact, mandate that people buy their insurance, so they can further enrich themselves!

    2. Stricter regulations for the Insurance companies, and hope they comply, but also include a Public Option like Medicare for ANYONE who wants to buy into it.

    3. Single-payer Public Health Insurance, where everyone pays in and everyone is served.

    And this should be done IRV-style, where voters can rank their choices. That way it will be as clear and informative a vote as we can get on what People REALLY WANT.
    Oh yeah, and make it BINDING, of course!
  • mmeflutterbye
    I don't like the conservadems. I especially detest Max Bogus for acting as though he wants to pass a helpful bill...YOU LIE! Max.
  • erroll
    With contributions that Baucus and other politicians have received from the health care industry, it is no wonder that single payer stood no chance of ever being considered as a true option for the American people.
  • afblac
    These Senators took an oath to uphold the Constitution. They have an ethical responsibility to represent the people of their state and to protect the nation. What Baucus has done is criminal as well as unethical. He has turned his back on his state and the nation for money. That is also the definition of treason. We have a public health crisis in this country. An epidemic could spread quickly. People without healthcare prevent a risk to themselves and the population. He is not protecting the population, but instead has chosen to work for the interests of the healthcare industry as the expense of people's lives. I can't imagine a more vile betrayal than what Baucus has done to the people of this country.
  • chabuka
    I don't get it..most every one realizes what is going on...the lobbyists, the donations (bribes) to politicians from the private Health Care Insurance Companies, the very "special" cadillac Health Care that Congress enjoys (that we pay for) the lies, the political stonewalling, the watered down P.O. (the triggers, how few will qualify, the mandatory clauses, etc.) at least two thirds of the public support a robust P.O. (most support single-payer, Medi-Care for all) and what we get is NO...from bothe sides of the aisle...why aren't we in the streets....why aren't we forcing this...? If a PRO protest happens and FOX doesn't "cover" it...does that mean its not seen or heard by any one in Congress, in the White House.....? If we don't get this P.O....we have only ourselves to blame...
  • Bia Winter
    Good question, Chabuka! I was invited by twice, by e-mail and phone to a Single-payer demonstration in Augusta Maine last week. Couldn't get anyone to come with me...then I couldn't FIND anyone, but saw a group of people in front of the State Capitol, and went there with my sign "Heathcare, NOT WARfare!" ....should've known they were Repugs, with all the flag overkill...it was a group announcing the candidacy of a Republican for governor, with a big sign, their new slogan "Working People Vote Republican" (Like, WHY!?)
    Obviously, this was where our demonstration SHOULD have been, and where the only "press" was....what a pathetic bunch of Apathy! No wonder we can't get any traction on this!
  • nader paul kucinich gravel
    Honesty compassion intelligence guts?
    We have an ongoing American Holocaust.
    Do you still want to believe what you were told about 9/11?
    The guilty are busy importing private mercenaries to hide behind.
  • octive9
    So why isn't someone charge them with bribery?
  • dennycrane
    The more you "give" into them, the more AstroGlide you have to buy. Aetna just notified some of its "clients" that they will be increasing their premiums by 47%. Gee, this extra money just paid off the fucking politicians to "kill" more people. "Just die quicker"........
  • philedrifter
    That settles it, I need to become a senator, then I can roll in dough. I'm the only person I know I can trust to make the right decisions, regardless of how much money they give me.

    /ya rly
  • tvfreezone
    I think the Dems are going to make a statement with a strong public option that will pass the house and be incorporated into the merged bill and then signed by Obama. Read it and weep, you corporate creeps.
  • musashi
    proving once again that prostitution is legal only in nevada and dc,
    congress is cesspool of corruption, no campaign reform NO DEMOCRACY!
  • tacticalgrace
    Can you say bribery boys and girls.............
  • imwc
    give so more will die...
  • shelial
    Any elected official that takes or has taken money (money going to pacs included) from the medical, insurance or big phama should not be allowed to vote on health care reform - it is a conflict of interest
  • sphere
    this just goes to tell you that all of congress are in with lobbiest
  • saxdog2005
    All you have to do is look at the money to see that the whole health care reform thing is a sham. It won't happen. Politicians want to get re-elected, so they have to stroke us and give the illusion that they want things to change. But I'm sure they don't want to lose the tens and sometimes HUNDREDS of thousands of dollars they get from the health care industry.
    Max Baucus, whose bill is currently at the top of the charts, is the biggest recipient of health care dollars in the democratic party. Can he REALLY be trusted? Can ANY of them??

    Even Al Franken has accepted over $15,000. I thought better of you Al.

    I have long thought that we live in the fall of Rome. America was a great country, but now it seems that votes and issues are bought, not voted for by the people. The people have no real representation. Apathy? Hell yes. How can people afford to make a dent in the 'free speech' and influence that millions of dollars from big industry can buy? The toilet has been flushed, people, and we're spiraling towards the drain. It's just a matter of time, in my opinion.
  • Elaine
    What happened to The Republic of the United States of America? What happened to "WE the PEOPLE" and liberty and justice? We are a nation of FREE and INDEPENDENT Individuals who are all entitled to rights and liberties that cannot be usurped by a federal government. What has corrupted this nation to the point that we are debating how we are to be further enslaved and taxed to the point where we merely work to pay debts we have not agreed to make? Our agreement has not been obtained to sell us further into enslavement! The Federal Government should have no say in our health care decisions. It is a personal choice! We should return to private doctor/patient patterns we once knew were right. The only health insurance Americans used to have, and rightly so, was Catastrophic health insurance. Other than that, we all went to the doctor and personally paid our bill and it was not through the roof. Reasonable medical bills went out the window when GREED flew in with insurance companies and the demand of socialism's egregious usurpation and redistribution of an individuals hard earned wealth! That is unAmerican.
blog comments powered by Disqus