In Arizona, death row may soon be run by private industry: report

By Stephen C. Webster
Saturday, October 24th, 2009 -- 1:26 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This!

prison In Arizona, death row may soon be run by private industry: reportThe State of Arizona, seeking to close a $2 billion budget gap, is planning to open bidding on all but one of its prison facilities.

Included in the offerings to private firms is an opportunity to manage the captivity of those condemned to die: a move that, for the first time ever, would put a U.S. state's death row in corporate hands, according to The New York Times.

"While executions would still be performed by the state, officials said, the Department of Corrections would relinquish all other day-to-day operations to the private operator and pay a per-diem fee for each prisoner," the Times added.

Todd Thomas, a warden who works at a Corrections Corporation of America facility in Eloy, AZ, told the paper that he's skeptical as to whether any private entity would ever want to manage a state's death row because "the liability is too great."

Privatizing all the state's prisons would close about $100 million of the state's $2 billion budget gap, the Times added.

Story continues below...

"The growing shortfall, roughly a fifth of the budget, prompted calls to cut spending, increase taxes and raid voter-mandated programs," the Associated Press reported on Friday.

To close the gap, "[state] agencies are proposing early prison release of a fourth of convicted felons, eliminating health care for children of the working poor and slashing so many police officers that the director of Department of Public Safety said will make Arizona 'open territory’' for smugglers," Arizona newspaper The Douglas Dispatch noted.

Other proposals being considered include halting the monitoring of air quality for a number of toxic pollutants, eliminating state monitoring of loan agencies and mortgage brokers, doing away with tutoring programs at public schools and even cutting off state funds for school safety officials, the Dispatch added.

About 30 percent of Arizona's 40,000 inmates are already held by private operators. The state has 10 prisons, nine of which are expected to be ceded to private control under the new proposals. A Corrections Corporation spokeswoman told the Times that the firm will bid on "at least some" of the prisons.

Corrections Corporation is the largest private prison company in the United States.

"It is unclear how well the state would do financially with the privatization," the Times continued. "[A] 2001 study found that private prisons save most states very little money. Indeed, many states, struggling to keep up with the cost of corrections, have closed prisons when possible and sought changes in sentencing to reduce crowding in the past two years."

Arizona's Republican Governor, Jan Brewer, supports a temporary sales tax increase as an alternative to deep budget cuts targeting voter-mandated safety net services.

Share this article:
  • Print this article!
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Story comments are below...
  • staunchdem
    Ending Ronnie Raygunz phony war on drugs, with it's mandatory minimum sentances would save us billions of dollars.
    We are the only country on earth to jail so many of it's citizens.
    It's just more debt created by Ronnie's policies and it's high time we stopped it.
  • commonwealth
    Maybe they can bid out executions too. Let the private sector handle it.

    They can take bids from the mafia to liquidate people. But, since we live in a global economy, countries that love to execute like Cuba, Iran, and North Korea can get in on the bidding. My guess is that China would be the cheapest.
  • bayside
    Arizona talk to tenn. They have a private run prison and judges on the payroll to fill them up.......Your going to be rich
  • bayside
    During ron reagans administration much was taken away from the govt. and privatized. This mess we have today is the result. Greed , power and blood at expense of public..........
  • overdoneputaforkinit
    The true cost of the wars has finally come home. If the terrorists would have released 1/4 of the felons, eliminated health care for children of the working poor and slashing so many police officers that the director of Department of Public Safety said will make Arizona 'open territory’' for smugglers, that would be quite a terrorist victory. But Bush got to pose in his cowboy boots and big hat and talk tough for a TV feel good moment 7 years ago.
  • Talk about a PERVERSE INCENTIVE.
  • dennycrane
    Just ask the christers to "chip" in more. They are against abortion, but for the "death" penalty. They can just "nail" people on trees or crosses like their enemies did to their christ. What's the cost for a few nails? Which brings us into the "modern" times. If "christ" was served the "death penalty" today, it would be by "lethal injection." So, you christers should be wearing "hyperdermic needles" around your necks instead of the "cross." It would be nice to drive by the "christ" caves and see "needles" embedded to the architect of the buildings.
  • airjackie
    Looks like Arizona is willing to kill innocent people and even increase citizens taxes at the same time. Looks like Arizona Republican Party has found a way of reducing the equal vote problem. Now Republicans will be free to kill those who don't vote Republican and even allow those to die who can't afford Health Insurance. Immigrants will be used to work and then killed after their service. Minorities will be owned again. Arizona will become the first State to bring down Civil Rights and Woman's Rights. It will be interesting to see how this plan works or will the people take the State back from the Dictators. At lease the Governor is giving Rush Limbaugh something to smile about and Senator Grandpappy McCain can get re elected for all the white racist voters. Maybe others will follow suit as this is some plan.
  • imwc
    oh...some more "no bid contracts"...?...
  • Robert
    Why don't we just privatize "The United States of America?" The whole damn country!!! Isn't that the way we are already heading? You can't vote out heads of privatized institutions! You can, however, vote out those people, or the party, running OUR government!! Wake up people! Call me crazy, but I do trust the government! A competent government that is accountable to the people of this country, not to the corporations or institutions that truly run a persons life. "Power to the People"! "Majority Rules"! "Minority is Protected"! "Real Human Rights"! "A True Secular Society"!
  • socialismorbust
    Vote out John McCain and let him be warden; he'd LOVE that.

    Seriously, what the fuck has happened to sanity in this country? Next they will privatize....Nope, I won't say it because it might be next!
  • Just
    Didn't Blackwater teach anything about privatization? Arizona is already a smugglers mecca. Sheriff Joe tries his best to curb the influx of crime in Maricopa County. No jurisdiction outside of Maricopa besides, for his efforts, is constantly badgered by "the elements" . If they would use the lottery funds for its "supposedly" original intention (education, law enforcement, health, etc.) they would be in better shape. Let the many agencies dipping into the pool (like Sierra Club) do their own fund raisers.
  • WJM51
    So rather than just look at the laws they shove down everyone's throats and eliminate the ones that don't actually HELP anything, they will take what will ultimately be the WRONG course of action and "privatize" their prison system. That will then become as for profit as it is anywhere else, and the next thing you know, it will be costing them 10 TIMES what it costs then now.

    Look at Colorado. 25 years ago, before we privatized OUR prisons here, we spent $70 million on the entire DOC. Now, after the privatization of pretty much the whole system, we spend $770 Million PER YEAR on prisons. It won't be any different in AZ, either, and what they did to save money will cost the FAR more than it does now. When profit is the motive, EVERYTHING becomes an excuse to lock people up.

    You are just screwing yourselves and your citizens, AZ. Mark my words, this will NOT turn out well for them, any more than it has for the rest of us.
  • socialismorbust
    CAPITALISM MUST GO!!!
  • WJM51
    Talk about not getting the point of a comment.

    Some things the gov't SHOULD be responsible for. In our society, prisons should be high on that list. The way we have done things, it's profitable for people to be locked up and their lives ruined. It's not about justice, it's not about truth, it's not about fairness. It's about how much money can we steal from someone? Funny, that is pretty much what extortion is about, isn't it?
  • Notorious Kelly
    The only way this can get better is if politicians own stock in the company that keeps their constituents locked up.

    "Parole?!? Oh I don't THINK so homey - we lose money if we let you out!"
  • yvonne
    If you want to guarantee that the cost to the taxpayer will quadruple (at least), privatize govt services.

    If you want to create a market that creates unprecedented profits, you must first create a need or demand that requires the product that you are selling. Privatizing govt services--oh, boy--what a boon for the corporate powers! It opens up all sorts of potentially profitable corporate markets--and all at a substantially higher cost to the taxpayers.

    If you want to guarantee that private prisons and their stockholders profit and flourish, you create an endless need or demand for your product (prisons), and in the private prison business that means using your political influence to lobby for more criminal laws that make it possible for more Americans to become convicted criminals--requiring more prisons in which to incarcerate them. And as a side benefit--another potentially profit-making market opens up--a slave labor market. Again, just use that corporate influence and lobby for legislation that puts profits over people.

    Oh, yeah, and let's not forget--they'll get to kill people too. How about that, huh? Private corporations executing people--now there's a market. How much more do you suppose these corporate prisons will charge the taxpayer for execute people? How much of a profit do you suppose the shareholders will make on that deal? Hey, maybe there's another profitable market in the making here...hmmmm. It's a win-win for the corporate beast, but a no-win for the people.

    This is not what capitalism is supposed to be about--this is sick, twisted, perverted--INSANE!!

    But most importantly, what about the unconstitutionality of all of this?
  • nader paul kucinich gravel
    Blackwater/Xe
  • imwc
    perdium...?...didn`t i hear that word associated with airhead barbie..?...
  • imwc
    per-diem...?...
blog comments powered by Disqus